I disagree, but that’s ok. Statements like, “All of the XYZ is designed to be inflammatory.” are themselves inflammatory. Why is it so hard to have an objective, data-based conversation about smaller calibers, just like we do all day with the larger calibers?
Margins. Yes. Control and accuracy are another end of the margins spectrum. There are plenty of real world reports about people shooting various Weatherby calibers that illustrate this. The ones that can control and be accurate with such calibers are sitting pretty!
There are Weatherbys, (eh) and then there are Weatherbys (yeah!).
There is a vast difference between the two!
Weatherby (yeah!) means the rifle is chambered for Weatherby designed ammo only. ie. 300 Weatherby, 460 Weatherby, etc, etc.
Then there's
Weatherby (eh) means it is a Weatherby rifle but chambered to fit the common calibers 300WM, 458WM, etc, etc.
The difference between the two are and have been the topic/complaint for generations past, present, and future.
IMO you used a bad example using Weatherby as a comparison.
You would be better off comparing Remington to Savage or Mossberg.
________________________________________________
Why is it so hard to have an objective, data-based conversation about smaller calibers, just like we do all day with the larger calibers?
I would be for an objective conversation for small bore calibers in the same manner as we have for big bore calibers.
Now, Let's discuss finding a (1) PH, a (1) tracker, who will risk their lives and yours to shoot any of the Dangerous 7 with your smaller bore, because you are of the opinion your small bore is just as effective as a big bore.
Or perhaps be a bit more fair we discuss your small caliber using heavy for caliber bullets versus a bigger caliber using a proper weight bullet both bullets traveling at 2700+, 2800+, 2900+/- fps velocity once it hits the 4th rib bone solid center mass, on a quartering away shot, on an eland at 300 yards.
Since this is a hypothetical discussion we can discuss kinetic energy as in foot pounds of knock down power.
Even better we will omit custom reloads and just compare factory available ammo.
________________________________________________
Or
We can have a more, better, informative discussion on small caliber optimums for small to medium game. And what small caliber, bullet weight, bullet velocity, etc works best for hunting certain species.
Pretty much the same as we discuss bigger bores on large game.
________________________________________________
Oh yeah,.....We are discussing legal firearms for Africa and Canada and pretty worldwide,....minus USA.....your AR is history. Your only firearm action choices are: double, bolt action, or lever action (where legal), rifle.