375Fox
AH legend
- Joined
- Feb 19, 2020
- Messages
- 4,022
- Reaction score
- 13,284
- Location
- Pennsylvania
- Media
- 172
- Hunted
- Zambia, Namibia, South Africa, Zimbabwe, Cameroon
You lowered your standards when you posted the insulting meme against the anti-CBL side.I was not going to lower my standards and answer your insulting posts but decided against my better judgment. First and foremost, I've never claimed to be an expert on anything. You on the other hand seemed to have an "answer & the right answer" to just about anything being posted here even from South African. What I've been saying all along is to respect to be respected. If you don't like that type of hunting (oops sorry shooting for you, oh and more on this) then leave it alone. My choice not yours. I'm sure you'll be happy when ARs (sporting rifles) are banned from hunting too.
To answer your questions.
1. No I have not visited any of them, and never claimed that I did. Now my question to you, is how many have you visited? You have any proofs? Oh, and don't post pictures from the internet. Show me proof that you took those pictures. How many farms where CBL is practiced have you visited?
2. I'm no expert, and I've never claimed to be. What makes you an expert on the subject? Oh wait, you read everything from SAPA guidelines, and DSC/SCI/CIC, NSA, FBI, JOB. Got it. Ask the dentist from Minneapolis who shot a wild lion how much support he received from SCI, or from some on this forum. Where is all your evidence, where are all your pictures of the places you've visited showing everything you seem to be have knowledge of?
3. Tracking experience. You know, I at least have the decency of not insulting others on their practices. When was the last time you actually did any hunting in which you tracked the animal yourself? Mr. Hunter (you), you've participated in a tracking experience too. If the PH in front of you doesn't tell you to shoot, you can't shoot. And if the black tracker in front of the PH doesn't know where he is going, you my friend don't know either. So, when the PH tells you to shoot, you shoot. You are also a shooter not a hunter. So quit patting yourself on the back and claiming that you are this great hunter, when in reality you are just a shooter who participated on a tracking experience like the rest of us.
4. It seems like you are the only one with an opinion that matters. Who died and made you king of South Africa, and who do you think you are to tell the South Africans how to run their country and what to do in their country. Mind your own business, and let the Africans deal with their issues. If you don't like their practices, you have a choice and don't go there. Simple! Did you read 20,000 Elephants to Germany? You want to read it, you may end up learning something.
5. Your hypocrisy has boundaries. You claim to have this passion (more like being a fanatic) against CBL, and you argue every time CBL is mentioned. I believe you have notification when the three letters pop up, you get an alert on your phone. But you don't say a word about the deer farming in the US, where you can go and purchase a deer with antlers out of this world, and you pay by the inches. You are taken to this wild area (sarcasm) and shoot this deer from an elevated platform. Or the Bison "hunting" farms where you go into a pasture, and you shoot the only Bison within miles. Oh, but that's ok? The pot calling the kettle black!
One final note. You seem to be an expert on everything, and you seem to get off on insulting people when things do not go your way. You even called out @IvW. I'm sure he is more of a hunter with more experience than you'll ever dream of having. Oh, and he is not a shooter like you are. For someone as vocal as you are, you seem to like hiding behind the keyboard and blocking your face from your pictures. I wonder what are you afraid of? Grow up and stop staying at the Holiday Inn Express. You can't be an expert by staying there all the time. Oh, and the ignore button is a beautiful thing. Have a wonderful day!
Your specific questions.
1. I have visited no farms where CBL is practiced. I really don’t care if it’s 1000 acres or 100,000. They are raised as farm animals and released a short time prior to your shoot. SAPA has YouTube videos of how they are raised. I don’t expect an invitation to visit a lion breeding farm to show my own photos.
2. I have read all the resources I can find on CBL. I did it so I could intelligently respond to some of the false facts that get put out there by pro-CBL crowd to support their cause. The pro-CBL crowd operates primarily on emotion. A few do present some logical arguments, but It’s clear to me when these threads come up that the pro-CBL crowd has not read any of the resources available. The legal bone trade is the only potential positive aspect I see to the CBL industry.
3. I’m not insulting your tracking experience. I simply don’t agree with the excuse that it covers up how the lions arrived there and the controversy they cause.
4. The South Africans can deal with their own matters without criticism when it doesn’t affect hunting outside their borders. South African breeders combine cub petting and lion experiences, the bone trade, and lion shooting into the CBL industry. They’ve made it an international business. Now it receives international condemnation. It is South Africa banning the practice.
5. I don’t support farm raised deer hunting. You’ve seen no posts of me supporting it and I have zero interest in participating. However, it does not cause the damage CBL causes so I’ll overlook it. I unknowingly shot put and take sable and that is now part of my objection to all put and take hunting. Hypocrisy to me though is continually saying we need to stand together as hunters but then saying you know more than all major hunting organizations that are against the practice.
I do make it a point to bring facts to this argument. That’s why I reference the sources I do. Those facts unfortunately devalue your trophy. I write quite extensively about my hunts and where I’ve hunted. I don’t show my face on a fully public forum, but I am quite open about my hunting especially by PM or phone call if you’d like to talk or at a future DSC show. IvW I do not believe to be who he presents himself as but I’ll never know. The ignore button is for individuals who don’t want to educate themselves both on what they support or on what they are against. I have lost respect for quite a few over this debate, but I’ll continue reading their posts to educate myself.