458 Win Mag vs 458 Lott....The facts

Yes indeed, one must know his rifle.

This paper-patch-BPCR method of Randolph S. Wright may be adapted for comparing throats (excellent book):

z005.JPG


z006.JPG


z007.JPG


My doodling on a tool:
0-1.JPG
 
Last edited:
I will try to reply to everything. If I miss something let me know.

All of these rifles were bought used. Though, all appeared as dang near new, literally.
So, I am assuming the throats were as factory reamed.
The MRC magazine is a nominal 3.6", perhaps a tiny longer. I actually load it to 3.5960" to allow me, real or imagined comfort level on COL and ogive variations.

The Winchester Model 70 Super Express throat surprised the heck out of me. I measured, re-measured and Re-measured ...
But, they came out consistent. This one may be a potential candidate for one of the spare 3.6" replacement magazines that I have around here. But, I will probably be putting it in a fiberglass stock, before the additional recoil. I would say throat erosion is not a factor on this one. It literally looked like new. I think I got 2 or 3 boxes of the Hornady super-whatever 500 grain with it, missing with 2 or 3 fired brass in one box.

The CZ had a trip to AHR prior to my purchase. But it also looked new. Now that one, I never bothered to measure. I shot some factory loads through it. I sort of did, but realized the 450's were dang near out of the brass, and the test COL cartridge from the MRC at 3.8205" worked through the magazine without issue. And called it good enough since all my Lott loads were for the MRC. Heck, I just "assumed" it was a SAAMI Winchester throat. Which would have been no issue with the MRC loaded lengths since I was not looking to maximize it.

Edit: I had a picture of the AHR work order on the CZ. No chamber work was listed.
 
Last edited:
Just for interest, from left to right. 458 Express 3” (shooter shoots a 500 gr Peregrine solid bullet at 2250fps from a Brno ZKK 602), 458 Lott (500gr Impala solid at 2272 fps - CZ550), 458 Win Mag (500gr Claw soft, 2170fps - Brno zkk 602). Note seating depths
 

Attachments

  • IMG_8304.jpeg
    IMG_8304.jpeg
    1.9 MB · Views: 6
Just for interest, from left to right. 458 Express 3” (shooter shoots a 500 gr Peregrine solid bullet at 2250fps from a Brno ZKK 602), 458 Lott (500gr Impala solid at 2272 fps - CZ550), 458 Win Mag (500gr Claw soft, 2170fps - Brno zkk 602). Note seating depths
Always of interest.
What are the Cartridge Overall Lengths of those ?
 

Forum statistics

Threads
57,910
Messages
1,242,798
Members
102,303
Latest member
ConserveZim
 

 

 

Latest profile posts

Grz63 wrote on Werty's profile.
(cont'd)
Rockies museum,
CM Russel museum and lewis and Clark interpretative center
Horseback riding in Summer star ranch
Charlo bison range and Garnet ghost town
Flathead lake, road to the sun and hiking in Glacier NP
and back to SLC (via Ogden and Logan)
Grz63 wrote on Werty's profile.
Good Morning,
I plan to visit MT next Sept.
May I ask you to give me your comments; do I forget something ? are my choices worthy ? Thank you in advance
Philippe (France)

Start in Billings, Then visit little big horn battlefield,
MT grizzly encounter,
a hot springs (do you have good spots ?)
Looking to buy a 375 H&H or .416 Rem Mag if anyone has anything they want to let go of
Erling Søvik wrote on dankykang's profile.
Nice Z, 1975 ?
Tintin wrote on JNevada's profile.
Hi Jay,

Hope you're well.

I'm headed your way in January.

Attending SHOT Show has been a long time bucket list item for me.

Finally made it happen and I'm headed to Vegas.

I know you're some distance from Vegas - but would be keen to catch up if it works out.

Have a good one.

Mark
 
Top