Which Buffalo Would You shoot?

[Hunting Hitman]

You are all wrong…buy the extra tag and shoot them both!

HH

 

[30.06king]

Both have very desirable features as trophies. I would guess both are mature, or close to mature, but not as old as they should be when taken as trophies. Unfortunately the pic doesn't show enough but I would want to assess body mass and other signs of great age before a decision to shoot. If neither was of takeable status I would be quite happy to let them walk, happy with the privilege of just finding such magnificent bulls to view. But agreed, they are beauties, both.

 

[Zinz]

Left one, for sure

 

[WAB]

Genetics are great but neither look to be very old. Maybe 7 or 8?

 

[shootist~]

Left.

 

[Doug Hamilton]

I took this picture at Lake Nakuru National Park in Kenya about 20 years ago. The question is, which one would you shoot? I'm torn, but I think I'd shoot the one on the left. How about you?

One of those times when you trust the judgement of your PH. That's one of the reasons you're paying him all that money.

 

[DillonG]

Left, bulls with the really nice drop just look cool.

 

[Monski]

The one on the left.

 

[CZDiesel]

The one on the right! I lean right not left!!! lol

 

[MS 9x56]

Left one has better boss but that tore up ear on right one makes him a fighter. More character I d take him.

 

[Muting the Goat]

Left one has better boss but that tore up ear on right one makes him a fighter. More character I d take him.

The one on the right does look like a scrapper.

 

[Muting the Goat]

The one on the right! I lean right not left!!! lol

Taking out something on the left isn't all bad.

 

[Muting the Goat]

Both have very desirable features as trophies. I would guess both are mature, or close to mature, but not as old as they should be when taken as trophies. Unfortunately the pic doesn't show enough but I would want to assess body mass and other signs of great age before a decision to shoot. If neither was of takeable status I would be quite happy to let them walk, happy with the privilege of just finding such magnificent bulls to view. But agreed, they are beauties, both.

They were a sight to behold. Lake Nakuru was full of big bulls. I was drooling...

 

[Muting the Goat]

Genetics are great but neither look to be very old. Maybe 7 or 8?

Probably young, but great genetics. Both will be monsters eventually.

 

[Carson]

This is not a matter of opinion. The left one is clearly and objectively better.

 

[sgt_zim]

I've said it before, I'll say it again: I want an OLD warrior who's earned a good death - horns worn down, missing half an ear, claw scars all over his back, teeth nearly worn down, a broken tail...

Those are some nice-looking bulls, just not my cuppa.

 

[meigsbucks]

Decisions, decisions.
The one on the left’s drop is special. However, I’d probably go with the right.

 

[Firebird]

The middle one

 

[baxterb]

left. get those horn tips low low

 

[Muting the Goat]

The middle one

The middle one is the one I shot!