I have been reading this for months and believe that the self proclaimed Africa hunting tipping mavens have pretty much well exhausted their fountain of splendiferousjy egotistically enhanced "do as I if you want to be in with the in crowd *.
I personally believe that many of the people who ask the questions here are doing so to just not be embarrassed when the end of the hunt draws near and tipping time approaches.
After all, does anyone really like to look like the poor stepchild?
Does anyone here who is monied actually need someone else's advice on who to and how much to tip them?
I sure as hell did need anyone's advice here how to make my money in my lifetime and I'd be damned that unless they are stuffing money in my pocket now that I would accept their snobbish ramblings as the only truth there is.
So maybe people need to put things into perspective before THEY decide what to throw out of their wallet.
(1) No matter how much money you have, you are not obligated to enrich the poor of the world.
(2) when you go to a dinner for a meal do you go into the kitchen and tip the cooks? The dishwasher? The cashier? The guy who washed the windows? The manager?
(3) When you play a round of golf you get a caddy who gets paid through the club who bills you. Do you tip the caddy who hands you your putter when your 60 yards from the Green?...or is on the cell phone the whole round?
(4) when you go on a cruise do you tip the guy why steers the ship or sits in the engine room? Do you tip the chefs? Tip the guy who paints the ship?
(5) And though I didn't think it possible I watched a guy who didn't shoot anything get brow beaten into tipping 4 Skinner's who skinned nothing for him. Would you?
Tipping is a very old custom in Africa. At one time only the very rich could afford to travel and hunt there. Agreements were made with tribal chiefs to get Skinner's, bearers, and such and the head man got paid. To keep the natives from walking off they would be given things as tips.
But do some of the people who work with you on your hunt deserve some of your hard earned loot?
I would say yes! When I was younger I went footstep for footstep with a tracker who insisted on carrying my rifle and he about ran me ragged. He trotted me for about ,4 hours straight and when he handed me my rifle we were about 30 yards from Target.
I have known ph's who were absolutely fantastic and did everything but carry the hunter to where he needed to be. I had one come to my room with a bottle and 2 glasses and cleverly asked if I was a shooter.When I said yes he said thank God and that in the 2 previous weeks his last two hunters couldn't hit a buffalo in the ass with a broom and that he was now almost out of ammo.
He did find game and said a few times that here were bigger ones to shoot and we went there and scored.
So there are those who do deserve something extra, but that amount is really up to you.
And for piss poor service don't be afraid to speak up to the outfitters and not tip at all.
I thought about letting this one go, and then, oh what the heck.
If you'd have split your post into two parts, you'd have been on to something.
The first part, which I'll call "the rant", seems to indicate some deep seated issues with people who might just have more money than you do. As well as those who certainly have a lot less. Or those who are "in". It's hard to tell. I'm not sure how you've managed to tie personal wealth or "enhanced egos" with views on tipping as expressed in this thread, but you seem to have accomplished it. Or maybe just assumed it. But for a very small number, virtually every post on this thread, other than those asking for advice, has been made with one thought in mind - trying to help those who have asked for help. Advice is just that, it's certainly not a rule, and very few to none of the posters have taken the attitude that they know best in every situation. They can only tell you what they've seen, or what they've done in their particular circumstances. Personally, I find that helpful. If you don't, well, you know best.
The second part of your post, which I'll call the "rational part" (and I include the last statement in that description), makes sense but, of course, it isn't at all helpful. You say that for those "who deserve something extra", give it to them, "but the amount is really up to you." Well, of course it is. But what people are asking for is exactly that - what is a reasonable amount in various circumstances? You've just told them to tip if they're happy. I really think we all already know that. What we want to know is how much. That's what those with some experience have tried to help with. And I hope they continue to do so, notwithstanding the rant.