Efred, in my case I only use Mauser action rifles . I have never owned another rifle brand like Winchester , Weatherby at all...and all my rifles are from many years back , every one older than myself ..the .375 H&H Magnum Coggswell & Harrison I currently own is more than sixty years of age ....as pointed out the licensing issues we are having in SA really is the deciding factor when moving to USA rifle brands like Weatherby...not a South African favorite at all with South African hunters since it is associated with extremely high velocities and light grain bullets that is a no, no here in SA,....most South African hunters use moderate velocity with heavy grain bullets for better /deeper penetration.
The only scenario the "high velocity /light grain bullets method of hunting /shooting is used here in SA is when hunters do varmint hunting and maybe target shooting out to longer distances than hunting scenarios...this is my opinion in regards to the foreign brands like the Weatherby rifles ..
Hi Gert - The licensing problems sound pretty bad. I envy you your Cogswell & Harrison, I've never seen one. Outside of major cities in the US, we have hardware stores and hardware store guns. I have a 30-06 Springfield, much like a Mauser, a 30-06 Remington 798, a Mauser, all "hardware store guns", as Rookhawk puts it. There is apparently a very different gun environment in Africa than exists in the US. With the internet, the situation is some improved here.
My .375 Weatherby, another "hardware store" gun, is about 150 fps faster than a 375 H&H, not an extreme difference, and it shoots 270, 300, and 350 gr bullets of sound construction. These aren't light bullets, nor are they excessive velocities. My .340 Weatherby is a little faster than a 338 WinMag, shoots the same range of bullet weights. The 300 Weatherby is a little faster than a 300 WinMag and shoots the same range of bullet weights. Again, not light weight bullets and not excessive velocities.
The 378 Weatherby is very fast for a .375 - I had the choice of a .375 and a .378, and I chose the .375, because the .378 seems too much, an opinion I think you'll share. Likewise the 416 Weatherby and 460 Weatherby, where I've chose .404 Jeffery (a Granite Mountain action and a Mark V action) and a 458 Lott in the Ruger RSM. Weatherbys in the range I'm discussing shoot the same weight bullets as the Mausers you refer to, at 100 to 150 fps higher velocity (factory ammo). Not light bullets, hardly excessive velocities, especially in view of the improved bullets now available.
There is no difference between a 375 Weatherby and a 375 AI ballistically - any criticism you can levy against the Weatherby you must levy against the AI also, except for licensing problems. In looking at an AI, you are looking for more powder capacity - more velocity for given bullet or more bullet for given velocity.
I was looking for a .375 H&H 15 yrs ago. The store I went to had a Ruger RSM, a Ruger African in 375 Ruger, and a CZ. The RSM was the nicest rifle, at twice the cost, but it was very muzzle heavy. I think Ruger used the same bbl size for the .375 and the .458 - worked well for 458, not so well for .375. The CZ didn't feel right to me, didn't come up easily, a bit blocky. I bought the African, due to its great balance, low weight, and powerful cartridge. Never regretted it. Love that rifle. For one reason or another, I never liked Remington or Winchester. I have a 30-06 Husqvarna that I really like - comes up right, light, no excess.
With heavy rifle experience, I doubt that you'd much notice the recoil difference between a .375 Weatherby and a 375 H&H. But not true for every client that you save - I feel for the man who buys a 378, 416, or 460 Weatherby for an Africa hunt without having shot a rifle before. He's in for a rude awakening, maybe a detached retina, and most likely he'll really need his PH. But there are a few others who have learned to shoot those monsters, like you with your heavy rifles, who'll likely do credit to themselves, and cause you little problem.
I wish you good luck and much enjoyment with your Mausers - you've had a lot already. If I were coming to Africa, I'd bring a .404 Jeffery and one of the following, depending on local terrain: 300 Wby Mag, 340 Wby Mag, 375 Ruger African. Most likely the 375 Ruger, because if you're hunting dik-dik in elephant country, you should prepare for elephant. I hope you'd support me in those choices, and wish me much fun and good luck!