Most efficient 3 cartridge spread for dangerous game?

Northern Shooter

AH elite
Joined
Mar 19, 2023
Messages
1,222
Reaction score
1,922
Location
Well North of Toronto.
Hunting reports
USA/Canada
1
Sure, there are many cartridges that will do-it-all and take everything from plains game to elephant.

But

If you were to choose 3 cartridges (+rifles) to hunt dangerous game. Which 3 would you choose?

A few thoughts:

A. 375--416--458
Basically small, medium and large. The 375 being arguably the most versatile African game cartridge for hunting plains game on up to elephant. The 416s as being similar to the 375 but being more ideal for larger game, less ideal for plains game(?). And the 458 for having the stopping power and authority on Buffalo on up that you don't get with the other two.

B. 375--470 NE--500 Jeff
Same as above except your cutting out the middle and reducing the overlap of the 375 & 416. Adding a 470 NE fills the middle the same as the 458 (similar ballistics/energy) but also opens up the options of carrying a double rifle. For anything above and beyond what you would conceivably need a 470 for, there's the 500J that will take anything and act as a stopping rifle moreso than anything else mentioned so far.

C. 404 Jeff--450 NE --505 Gibbs
The classic Africana threesome?

What combo would you consider? What would the most efficient spread consist of if you were to limit it down to three cartridges?
 
Last edited:
.308 (leopard)....bolt
.416 Rigby..........double
.458 Lott.............bolt

Just what I'm considering, really interested to hear others thoughts.
 
I started off with 375, then 458 WM. I'm now considering one of the 416s and/or a 470 but I'm also open to suggestions and curious to hear others reasoning.
 
Last edited:
300 win mag
375 H&H
404 Jeffery

I am having the 404 Jeffery built now, already have the 300 win mag and 375 H&H. I think this has me covered from the tiny 10 (375 with a solid) any plains game and any DG I might decide to go after.
 
In some ways, we may really be talking about buffalo, hippo and elephant? I’ve never heard that something more than a 375 is ideal for lion or leopard.

What’s best for buffalo is not best for elephant. But a third cartridge? I’d go with a 416, and two back up 416s…
 
.375
.375
.375
 
Sure, there are many cartridges that will do-it-all and take everything from plains game to elephant.

But

If you were to choose 3 cartridges (+rifles) to hunt dangerous game. Which 3 would you choose?

A few thoughts:

A. 375--416--458
Basically small, medium and large. The 375 being arguably the most versatile African game cartridge for hunting plains game on up to elephant. The 416s as being similar to the 375 but being more ideal for larger game, less ideal for plains game(?). And the 458 for having the stopping power and authority on Buffalo on up that you don't get with the other two.

B. 375--470 NE--500 Jeff
Same as above except your cutting out the middle and reducing the overlap of the 375 & 416. Adding a 470 NE fills the middle the same as the 458 (similar ballistics/energy) but also opens up the options of carrying a double rifle. For anything above and beyond what you would conceivably need a 470 for, there's the 500J that will take anything and act as a stopping rifle moreso than anything else mentioned so far.

C. 404 Jeff--450 NE --505 Gibbs
The classic Africana threesome?

What combo would you consider? What would the most efficient spread consist of if you were to limit it down to three cartridges?
375-470-500
 
.375 for leopard and elephant Red Leg?
Sure. There is no meaningful difference between a .270 gr SP .375 and a 200 gr SP .300 for leopard (I personally simply would use the 300gr A Frame). 300 gr A frame for everything but a tusker. 300 gr Hydro for the elephant. For a client, they all look just about perfect.

To be totally honest, were I going after a bull elephant this year, I likely would take a .404, 500/416. or .470 purely to finally use one of them. But, I would not be taking one because it realistically was superior to the .375.
 
Last edited:
375 H&H cats, Hippo in water
500/416 NE follow up cats and buff
500 Jeff follow up buff and elephant
 
450 No 2
475 No 2 Jeffery
500 NE
 

Forum statistics

Threads
59,669
Messages
1,295,970
Members
108,453
Latest member
LavonneX66
 

 

 

Latest posts

Latest profile posts

Hello! I’m new… from Texas!
schwerpunkt88 wrote on Robmill70's profile.
Morning Rob, Any feeling for how the 300 H&H shoots? How's the barrel condition?
mrpoindexter wrote on Charlm's profile.
Hello. I see you hunted with Sampie recently. If you don't mind me asking, where did you hunt with him? Zim or SA? And was it with a bow? What did you hunt?

I am possibly going to book with him soon.
 
Top