1." A .375 is all you need for any animal on Earth under ANY circumstances. Anything bigger is pointless "
- Yes , I know that good scores of African elephants and cape buffaloes are taken every year by client hunters with .375 Holland & Holland magnum calibre rifles . I personally am 1 of the largest proponents and admirers of the .375 Holland & Holland magnum calibre. I consider the pre 64 Winchester Model 70 to be the gold standard of hunting rifles for a shikaree intent on hunting the entire world with 1 rifle. The .375 Holland & Holland magnum deserves it's reputation as the most well liked shikar / safari rifle calibre of all time . However , the above quoted statement needs to be rectified. It is not designed as a charge stopper of heavy thick skinned game , such as gaur bison ( which can easily weigh over 2000 pounds , in the case of a fully grown male , which is around 700 pounds heavier than a Cape Buffalo ) or elephants , especially in the thickets . It is a good choice for PICKED SHOTS on game like gaur or elephants ( which is usually the kind of shooting afforded to client shikarees ) in open terrain . For frontal shots at charging gaur or elephants ( a task which is carried out by professional shikarees , who often need to perform said task in the most unfavorable of times ) , a bigger calibre employing a heavier bullet is always a good idea. For gaur , I would personally prefer at least a .450 calibre , employing at least a 500 grain bullet .
2." OO buck can flatten any charging leopard , any day "
I have genuinely wondered for MANY , MANY years since 1965 who originally came up with the idea of using letter shot on charging panthers , which can end up making you look like confetti if they get ahold of you .
If I ever met this person , then the only question which I would ask them , would be " How many charging leopards have you actually shot with OO buck shot successfully ? "
3. " Don't get a push feed rifle . They will jam on you "
What statements like this do is that they take an occurrence which happens under a VERY SPECIFIC SET OF CIRCUMSTANCES and generalize things as if this occurrence happens all the time .
While I personally do not prefer a push feed bolt rifle for dangerous game , the thought that it is unsuitable for ANY hunting is ludicrous , to say the least .
And for most client hunters , a push feed bolt rifle will leave very little ( if anything ) to be desired for even dangerous game .