Pheroze
AH ambassador
Jerome, we need a new forum please: divisive discussion/ politics, religion and calibers.
I find this stuff fascinating because the world is getting smaller an cultures are mingling. The USA is being influenced more from other countries than ever before in history. I am going to pick up that book Velo Dog.
Saul, I did read your post. There is a lot in there. I think we are agreed that we want a society that is fair to each persons circumstances. But, how of much of my responsibility to my neighbor do I delegate to the government?
The American constitution was written to control absolute power not to empower the state. That is why it is such a brilliant document, considering it was written several hundreds of years ago when there was no equality and Kings could cut your head off. When you go back and read the Federalist Papers you can see the fractious debate about whether to even have a central government. Great stuff! But, I think we are seeing a cultural shift in politics. A nanny state is a new idea (post WWII) and I do not think even Thomas Hobbes considered it when he wrote the Leviathan advocating for a strong central government. I personally blame the Baby Boomers
Europe has a political culture that looks to the government to intervene more on personal planning issues and the government taxes accordingly. While I believe Norway and Germany are doing fine Spain, Greece, Portugal etc not so much. And, how do we factor China and India into this? One is a communist government with a capitalist economy and the other is a democratic country with a socialist economy. Both are growing. Egads!!
And, I think the 375 H&H is over rated (umm just kidding...maybe....actually confused about that one...)
I find this stuff fascinating because the world is getting smaller an cultures are mingling. The USA is being influenced more from other countries than ever before in history. I am going to pick up that book Velo Dog.
Saul, I did read your post. There is a lot in there. I think we are agreed that we want a society that is fair to each persons circumstances. But, how of much of my responsibility to my neighbor do I delegate to the government?
The American constitution was written to control absolute power not to empower the state. That is why it is such a brilliant document, considering it was written several hundreds of years ago when there was no equality and Kings could cut your head off. When you go back and read the Federalist Papers you can see the fractious debate about whether to even have a central government. Great stuff! But, I think we are seeing a cultural shift in politics. A nanny state is a new idea (post WWII) and I do not think even Thomas Hobbes considered it when he wrote the Leviathan advocating for a strong central government. I personally blame the Baby Boomers
Europe has a political culture that looks to the government to intervene more on personal planning issues and the government taxes accordingly. While I believe Norway and Germany are doing fine Spain, Greece, Portugal etc not so much. And, how do we factor China and India into this? One is a communist government with a capitalist economy and the other is a democratic country with a socialist economy. Both are growing. Egads!!
And, I think the 375 H&H is over rated (umm just kidding...maybe....actually confused about that one...)