Politics

[Neophyte]

And our downward spiral continues.
It’s already been proven that communist, what democrats are, can’t fix the economy. I’m voting for the Second Amendment and the economy. Only one candidate is capable of doing that.

 

[Red Leg]

I think most people have foreseen this from the beginning. Do you actually believe Crimea was going to be returned to Ukraine? Also, those areas in the south and east have been a problem for quite some time. I think it’s naive to believe that things were going to return to normal after this is over. The way things are escalating I think it’s best to negotiate and end it. If we and others had been willing to give more support at the beginning it might’ve ended with a complete Russian withdrawal while retaining Crimea but that time has passed.

Taiwan is obviously an all or nothing situation unlike Ukraine. It’s plain to see for everyone at this point that Russia will most likely not be taking Ukraine in its entirety. The US and Europe are going to go for that. Now that Ukraine has invaded Russia proper they have some leverage for the negotiations that are increasingly likely and have been hinted at by both parties.

I’m curious what you thought the current or possible Harris administration was going to get accomplished?

Of course everyone in the world knows if Trump was in office the invasion wouldn’t have happened in the first place. Period.

The problem with your response, and frankly that of Vance who seems to be incredibly ignorant about Europe, is it ignores the reality of Ukrainian and Russian history, and the reality on the battlefield.

After being beaten back from Kyiv and driven from the Kharkiv province, in an act of political desperation, Russia announced the annexation of Luhansk, Donetsk, Zaporizhzhia and Kherson provinces. Even Donetsk, which had the largest Russian speaking population, is not fully under Russian control. The other provinces are truly Ukrainian. They voted in the mid 90th percentile to be part of Ukraine in the 1991 independence referendum. By the way, even Donetsk was in the high 80th percentile. Russia doesn't even hold the capitals of Luhansk, Zaporizhzhia, and Kherson. As @WAB notes, the Ukrainians have defeated the Russian Navy and Air Force in and above the Black Sea, putting Crimea at great risk (which voted in the 70th percentile to be part of Ukraine).

So, why on earth should the United States help Russia achieve its brutal strategic objectives which it is to date incapable of achieving on its own? Moreover, achieving those objectives would leave Russia stronger, and far more capable of putting pressure on Western Europe than at any point since the collapse of the Soviet Union. How is that in any way remotely in the interests of this country?

In turn, that growing Eurasian threat can only serve to divert our focus from the Pacific at a time when Chinese power is growing ever stronger. Hence, Xi's eagerness to demonstrate his support for Russia's initial invasion in February of 22.

When Vance ignorantly or naively (I am not sure which is worse) suggests Russia be allowed to simply achieve its war aims, we are allying ourselves with Vladimir Putin. It is simply incomprehensible to me any informed person would support such an outcome to this conflict or such behaviour by our leadership.

 

[Pondoro]

I am totally shocked if Trump and Vance really want to go this way...to handle Ukraine to Putin on a plate..their ignorance on this is nothing but scary..and cowardly..not to mention plain outright dangerous to western Europe..

How will the rest of NATO react to such a decision..? It will be a political 180 turn leaving the alliance in complete disarray.. !

This is what worry me most if those 2 get in power...

 

[wesheltonj]

I’ve never really understood the importance of the Russian Black Sea fleet. It has to travel through two NATO countries to reach the open sea. In a war with NATO, what is the likelihood that they would have free passage through Turkey and Greece? Slim and none come to mind.

 

[Pondoro]

I’ve never really understood the importance of the Russian Black Sea fleet. It has to travel through two NATO countries to reach the open sea. In a war with NATO, what is the likelihood that they would have free passage through Turkey and Greece? Slim and none come to mind.

They still have the ability to attack Ukraine and NATO states like Bulgaria, Romania and Turkey from where they are..if it should come to that..

In case of war with NATO they will never get to pass the Bosporus straight..