bruce moulds
AH legend
- Joined
- Aug 10, 2018
- Messages
- 2,871
- Reaction score
- 4,832
One thing new guys in reloading tend to do is to try and squeeze out every last FPS of velocity they can. If you're one of those guys who likes pushing the edge, that may be fun for you. If you just want to roll your own cartridges to get better precision than you can out of typical factory ammo, it's a waste of both time and money, and potentially dangerous.
The reason 100 or maybe even 200 fps doesn't make a lot of difference for me is because I sight my hunting rifles in for Maximum Point Blank Range for my given quarry. Using MPBR, nearly all modern, shouldered cartridges are "flat" shooting out to 250 or 300 yards; modern magnums can extend this to 325 or even 350 for bigger ruminants like moose and elk.
When working up a new load, this is the first place I start my research to figure out what it is I should be trying to accomplish: http://www.shooterscalculator.com/point-blank-range.php
We can start with one my pet loads for my 6.5x55 Swedish Mauser. Shooting Hornady ELD-X 143 gr, BC .625, at an 8" vital zone (white tail deer), I find that the difference between 2500 fps and 2600 fps is an additional 10 yards of MPBR, from 286 yards at 2500, to 296 yards at 2600 fps. Understanding this, when I started stacking bullets at 2500 fps very early in load development, I quit trying to improve velocity because it wasn't going to be any more accurate or lethal than what I already had.
Even more:
to reach a 286 yd MPBR at 2500 fps, I need to be 3.63" high at 100 yards, which gives me a far zero of 242 yards
to reach 296 yd MPBR at 2600 fps, I need to be 3.54" high at 100 yards, which gives me a far zero of 251 yards.
Heck, you might hit a mosquito in mid-flight which might deflect your shot as much as 9 hundredths. If you have a micrometer (should have one as a standard part of your kit), you'd still have a difficult time discerning the difference. The act of measuring your groups with a micrometer introduces a greater potential for variance that you'll get out of 2500 vs 2600 for this load.
Given that in any string of 20 cartridges you roll, you might get as many as 4 or 5 cartridges at exactly 2500 fps. You'll have a variance with the rest of them hopefully between about 2480 and 2520. Same thing if you were trying to hit 2600 fps. Bottom line is if one of your test strings hits the sweet spot for accuracy, then load development is over, and stick with that load. The best you can hope for if you keep testing is maybe another 30-40 feet on your MPBR. Sounds kind of silly to muck around with your load for a marginal improvement like that. If you were shooting Naitonal Match or F-Class or something similar, it might be worth it. For hunting, it just isn't.
what he said.
bruce.