Is your scope as good as your binoculars?

Not the Z8, but owned two Swaro scopes before including the vaunted 1-6 EE, along with four pairs of Swaro binos through the years. Reading three accounts of the Swaro scopes failing in this forum convinced me to sell the EE to someone who wanted it. Now I use Nightforce scopes, although do have a Trijicon 1-6 on the shelf to mount, and some Aimpoints. fwiw - one of the Aimpoint Comp M5's failed last week.
Now don't take this wrong but my point is here that there is no point in discussing the Z8 with someone who has not owned one. You just don't know what you're missing. Let me tell you it so so good that if I broke it I would immediately replace it with a new one. If you found something that was 10x better than anything else on the market, that you could see things you'd never seen before through a scope, would you take some rando's online advice and sell your optics and buy something different?
These discussion are fairly regular here and I just wish yall knew how terribly ignorant you are of the subject you wish to speak on.
If you have not used a Swarovski Z8 you don't know what is truly available in scopes today!
 
Now don't take this wrong but my point is here that there is no point in discussing the Z8 with someone who has not owned one. You just don't know what you're missing. Let me tell you it so so good that if I broke it I would immediately replace it with a new one. If you found something that was 10x better than anything else on the market, that you could see things you'd never seen before through a scope, would you take some rando's online advice and sell your optics and buy something different?
These discussion are fairly regular here and I just wish yall knew how terribly ignorant you are of the subject you wish to speak on.
If you have not used a Swarovski Z8 you don't know what is truly available in scopes today!
@Philip Glass , is there a quality difference between the Z6 and Z8? Is the Z8 more rugged than the Z6?

The reason I ask is that the Z6i I own is the nicest glass I've used, however it has to be returned for repairs for the second time now in 2 years.
 
Not Philip obviously but I own and use both Z6i and Z8i (2 of both). I haven't had any of them go down and need repairs in about 3 years of hard use, lots of trips, etc. So my experience has been equally good with both models.
 
Thank you Green Chile.

I’m derailing the thread, but this is how my Z6i currently looks:
IMG_8177.jpeg

Ironically it is at least holding zero after the last repair.
 
Now don't take this wrong but my point is here that there is no point in discussing the Z8 with someone who has not owned one. You just don't know what you're missing. Let me tell you it so so good that if I broke it I would immediately replace it with a new one. If you found something that was 10x better than anything else on the market, that you could see things you'd never seen before through a scope, would you take some rando's online advice and sell your optics and buy something different?
These discussion are fairly regular here and I just wish yall knew how terribly ignorant you are of the subject you wish to speak on.
If you have not used a Swarovski Z8 you don't know what is truly available in scopes today!

Ignorant? Interesting approach. You know zero of my background. I know zero of yours other than the presumptuous arrogance you are displaying.

Serious question - Is the Z8 constructed more robustly than all other Swaro scopes including the 1-6 EE?

You are discussing optical quality, but omitting discussion of reliability in your recommendation. Please tell us how the scope is working after it has at least a few thousand rounds on it or even 1,000. How many rounds have been fired under the Z8 you are using? That would be informative and helpful to evaluate it.

My point is very simple, reliability is critical, but is being omitted in your recommendation based on optical quality without consideration of reliability.

fwiw - I’ve shot pigs by moonlight with Nightforce, S&B, and Aimpoints. Is that good enough optical performance? How does the Z8 compare to a S&B Polar? Have you fired rounds in low light or moonlight without external illumination under one of those? How many rounds have you fired using a S&B PMII, Nightforce NXS, NX8, or ATACR?

You are discussing glass quality, but omitting discussion of reliability or other companies that deliver both.

If you want to toss around inflammatory slurs, please share with us your round count fired from centerfire rifles. How many barrels have you shot out in a year? Rounds fired is what has caused every optical failure I have encountered, except for one that happened due to a rifle knocked out of a truck. I did have a Nightforce survive being knocked off a bench and landing with the scope hitting concrete.

While I’ve slowed down as years add up on my hide, there was a time I was going through a barrel every two months and two cases/drums or more of powder a year. Firing rounds day after day in heat in temps over 110f to well below freezing tends to reveal weaknesses in scopes. While I am working on a ranch this weekend, I still will make time to shoot at least 50 rounds of .308 for practice and to evaluate velocity and DOPE of a load in temps over 100f, more likely over 105f. That heat also bakes scopes sitting in a drag bag in a buggy, so it is evaluating the scope, rifle, and load combination in the heat. I fully expect a scope, rifle, and ammo to be able to operate correctly and easily last exposed to that heat day after day and year after year.

fwiw - I have used, not owned, Hensoldt mil scopes that cost $12,000+, 20 years ago, in the short time they were offered to the civilian market. I could readily read newspaper headlines tacked to a target holder at 400 yards despite summer mirage. It combined robust mil grade durability with exceptional glass. It remains the best scope glass I have ever looked through combined with durability and reliability. It was at least as good or better than a Leica spotting scope next to it. Have you used a Hensoldt mil scope?
 
Last edited:
Leica bino's and Schmidt & Bender or Swaro rifle scopes for me.

I just want to go on record and say, IMO, there is no high-end rifle scope that is 10 times better than any of the other high-end scopes. Example, the top end Swaro and the top end S&B are probably directly comparable, however, the erectors in the S&B are probably more durable than the Swaro. I would say that the fact most elite military operators given the option of anything they desire, most would choose S & B. I have used both, and this is just my opinion. One thing there is no doubt about, Swarovski is an incredible marketing company and for sure has the largest market share for high end rifle scopes, binos, and spotters. Shame about Zeiss getting out of the sport optics market, smart though, they were never going to make a comeback with the brands that are out there currently.

I'd also go on record and say that IMO Leica are better than Swaro in the bino category across the board. We all have our opinions and from experience for sure
 
Leica bino's and Schmidt & Bender or Swaro rifle scopes for me.

I just want to go on record and say, IMO, there is no high-end rifle scope that is 10 times better than any of the other high-end scopes. Example, the top end Swaro and the top end S&B are probably directly comparable, however, the erectors in the S&B are probably more durable than the Swaro. I would say that the fact most elite military operators given the option of anything they desire, most would choose S & B. I have used both, and this is just my opinion. One thing there is no doubt about, Swarovski is an incredible marketing company and for sure has the largest market share for high end rifle scopes, binos, and spotters. Shame about Zeiss getting out of the sport optics market, smart though, they were never going to make a comeback with the brands that are out there currently.

I'd also go on record and say that IMO Leica are better than Swaro in the bino category across the board. We all have our opinions and from experience for sure
I agree with a lot of this but will also say the Kahles gets a lot of love when you talk to top military snipers and doesn’t Get mentioned nearly as much amongst hunters j talk to.
 
Thank you Green Chile.

I’m derailing the thread, but this is how my Z6i currently looks:
View attachment 705495
Ironically it is at least holding zero after the last repair.
I think you are trying to show the field of view with this photo, but I only (don’t) see the Swarovski crosshairs. It doesn’t matter to me how great their glass is when I can’t see the crosshairs easily. Without illuminated reticle and a charged battery Swarovski glass does mean much. I can shoot later with other brands because the crosshairs draw a contrast.
 
Not the Z8, but owned two Swaro scopes before including the vaunted 1-6 EE, along with four pairs of Swaro binos through the years. Reading three accounts of the Swaro scopes failing in this forum convinced me to sell the EE to someone who wanted it. Now I use Nightforce scopes, although do have a Trijicon 1-6 on the shelf to mount, and some Aimpoints. fwiw - one of the Aimpoint Comp M5's failed last week.
I alone have 2 different instances of a Nightforce failing. In both instances they were warrantied without issue. Maybe there’s one other AH member with a failure and we can all post and you’ll sell that NF.

That said, I still Trust NF and own an ATACR despite one previously failing.
 
I alone have 2 different instances of a Nightforce failing. In both instances they were warrantied without issue. Maybe there’s one other AH member with a failure and we can all post and you’ll sell that NF.

That said, I still Trust NF and own an ATACR despite one previously failing.
All things mechanical can break, it just is a question of frequency. Nightforce has held up better than most for me and most others. Never saw S&B or Hensoldt break either. Unfortunately lost an Aimpoint Comp M5 just last week.
 
I use Leica Geovid binos and a whole range of scopes. I don’t glass in Africa like I do in the western US states so the rifle has the better optics in Africa
 
Ignorant? Interesting approach. You know zero of my background. I know zero of yours other than the presumptuous arrogance you are displaying.

Serious question - Is the Z8 constructed more robustly than all other Swaro scopes including the 1-6 EE?

You are discussing optical quality, but omitting discussion of reliability in your recommendation. Please tell us how the scope is working after it has at least a few thousand rounds on it or even 1,000. How many rounds have been fired under the Z8 you are using? That would be informative and helpful to evaluate it.

My point is very simple, reliability is critical, but is being omitted in your recommendation based on optical quality without consideration of reliability.

fwiw - I’ve shot pigs by moonlight with Nightforce, S&B, and Aimpoints. Is that good enough optical performance? How does the Z8 compare to a S&B Polar? Have you fired rounds in low light or moonlight without external illumination under one of those? How many rounds have you fired using a S&B PMII, Nightforce NXS, NX8, or ATACR?

You are discussing glass quality, but omitting discussion of reliability or other companies that deliver both.

If you want to toss around inflammatory slurs, please share with us your round count fired from centerfire rifles. How many barrels have you shot out in a year? Rounds fired is what has caused every optical failure I have encountered, except for one that happened due to a rifle knocked out of a truck. I did have a Nightforce survive being knocked off a bench and landing with the scope hitting concrete.

While I’ve slowed down as years add up on my hide, there was a time I was going through a barrel every two months and two cases/drums or more of powder a year. Firing rounds day after day in heat in temps over 110f to well below freezing tends to reveal weaknesses in scopes. While I am working on a ranch this weekend, I still will make time to shoot at least 50 rounds of .308 for practice and to evaluate velocity and DOPE of a load in temps over 100f, more likely over 105f. That heat also bakes scopes sitting in a drag bag in a buggy, so it is evaluating the scope, rifle, and load combination in the heat. I fully expect a scope, rifle, and ammo to be able to operate correctly and easily last exposed to that heat day after day and year after year.

fwiw - I have used, not owned, Hensoldt mil scopes that cost $12,000+, 20 years ago, in the short time they were offered to the civilian market. I could readily read newspaper headlines tacked to a target holder at 400 yards despite summer mirage. It combined robust mil grade durability with exceptional glass. It remains the best scope glass I have ever looked through combined with durability and reliability. It was at least as good or better than a Leica spotting scope next to it. Have you used a Hensoldt mil scope?
I am in no way meaning to be insulting. You've cleared up that you are coming from a far different POV than I. You are an accomplished target shooter and I am a hunter who shoots a bit. On AH my POV is from the hunting scenario. I'm just saying that this comes up over and over and the person arguing has not owned a Z8. I'll give it to you on the round count. I need reliability in the field and I have that. I am ignorant (not a slur but a simple fact) of the Hensoldt scope. I am not a military guy, just a hunter.
 
Put me in the ignorant crowd. "Reliability" must be weighed against affordability. Am I going to buy a new Beamer sports car or a used SUV when they both get me from point A to point B? I have looked through expensive European scopes in the stores and also looked at their price tags. If there is a significant improvement, I can't see it. No, I don't bother flipping any switches. Don't hunt after dark or in waning light. I have always questioned the ethics. Also don't own a trail cam or drone ... or even a GPS. It's where I personally draw the line. I had a cheap Bushnell scope crap out back in the eighties but replaced it with a slightly more expensive Weaver K3 that's still kicking after forty years of hard use. Replaced it in 2018 with a Black Friday special $99 Nikon 3-9x that went back to the factory instantly. It's been fine since then. Both scopes have killed a pile of game. Until my second trip to Africa in 2020, I never hunted with binoculars. And I never felt handicapped without them. But my style of hunting before Africa was primarily tracking in snow in big timber. Binoculars would just be extra weight. Even after switching to open country about ten years ago I have rarely taken a shot further than 200 yards. Binoculars don't leave my vehicle. I know how to use the terrain and weather to get up close in open country. This buck was a long shot (actually, the longest) at 220 yards. I spotted him when he spotted me and I still had enough time to drop onto my butt and take him with one shot. I have taken four other nice bucks on the same public access property.
20231121_112734.jpg

Plains game in Africa is a bit different. I usually don't know the terrain or the habits of the game. Never any snow for tracking (but trackers don't seem to need it). I'm hunting with others so no swinging the muzzle around to scope animals. I have binoculars instead. And I don't have to carry anything but my gun so weight isn't an issue. Do they enhance my hunting experience? Not really. Too much fiddling and too hard to hold steady. Most of the time I don't want to be bothered with them. I'll let PH and tracker do the glassing. They have better eyes (much!) and they know what they're looking for.

Bottom line: I'm un-ignorant enough know what I'm missing is spending a pile of money on gadgets and luxuries that really won't increase my productivity or enhance my hunting experience enough to warrant their price tag. I'll save my money for more trips to Africa. Or maybe college educations for my grandkids.
 
I am in no way meaning to be insulting. You've cleared up that you are coming from a far different POV than I. You are an accomplished target shooter and I am a hunter who shoots a bit. On AH my POV is from the hunting scenario. I'm just saying that this comes up over and over and the person arguing has not owned a Z8. I'll give it to you on the round count. I need reliability in the field and I have that. I am ignorant (not a slur but a simple fact) of the Hensoldt scope. I am not a military guy, just a hunter.
You did preface the statement in question with "don't take this the wrong way"
 
All things mechanical can break, it just is a question of frequency. Nightforce has held up better than most for me and most others. Never saw S&B or Hensoldt break either. Unfortunately lost an Aimpoint Comp M5 just last week.
100% all things mechanical can break and they're all made by man with one of them being made first thing on a Monday or last on a Friday afternoon. Same with rifles.

I've used a NF way less than I have S&B, but had 2 failures. I've used S&B in both a personal and professional setting, yet never had an issue. I think I presently own about a dozen S&B scopes, while owning 1 NF and having only owned 2-3 of their optics. Maybe I got lucky, maybe I just jinxed myself on S&B ... either way I still trust NF, but trust S&B more and believe they're a little more reliable and durable.

@Philip Glass If one was trying to bridge the gap between optical clarity of Swaro and reliability while saving a little compared to a S&B PMII, the Kahles would get a hard look from me but you're going to lose the hunting look/feel Swaro gives
 
I've got a number of NF scopes and used to use them in the field a lot more (and still do on some match rifles). I still have a NF that gets used a fair amount on hunts...NX8 1-8x24 F1. I used it most recently on a .416 for lioness, nyala, wildebeest and bush pig (night). It worked great and the reticle drew a lot of positive comments from the PHs. Again, lighted reticle. I do like the feel of the clicks on a NF.

IMG_9357.jpeg

IMG_9249.jpeg
 
100% all things mechanical can break and they're all made by man with one of them being made first thing on a Monday or last on a Friday afternoon. Same with rifles.

I've used a NF way less than I have S&B, but had 2 failures. I've used S&B in both a personal and professional setting, yet never had an issue. I think I presently own about a dozen S&B scopes, while owning 1 NF and having only owned 2-3 of their optics. Maybe I got lucky, maybe I just jinxed myself on S&B ... either way I still trust NF, but trust S&B more and believe they're a little more reliable and durable.

@Philip Glass If one was trying to bridge the gap between optical clarity of Swaro and reliability while saving a little compared to a S&B PMII, the Kahles would get a hard look from me but you're going to lose the hunting look/feel Swaro gives
Very true. Kahles have a lot to offer. It is their red dot that I have on my double.
 
Phillip sent a very nice note offline to which I have replied.

We’re good. :)(y)

He is a good man and a true gentleman.
Thank you sir! All good
 

Forum statistics

Threads
62,521
Messages
1,373,186
Members
120,195
Latest member
Rblearkingte
 

 

 

Latest posts

Latest profile posts

I have an unfired T rex 577 if anyone is interested in acquiring it . Absolutely spotless, flawless and well kept . It's rare as it gets . Mouth watering ? Let me know if you feel like making an offer .
Mr Brown in Calif.
Nevada Mike wrote on 50reloader's profile.
I need to know if this is legit. Photo with today's paper would do it.

Thanks
Monster Impala for Ricky with his trusty bow !
01696dfa-f596-4f46-aafa-2d37c38f3493.jpeg
Andrew NOLA wrote on SethFitzke's profile.
I just saw Budsgunshop.com has both the guide gun and the African for $1150. FWIW - I bought both and decided to use the Guide gun - I restocked it in a Bell and Carlson stock and I added the Alaska arms floor plate to add a round. I wanted the shorter barrel as I will use a suppressor. I wont go lower than $1100, but I will ship it and no sales tax.

Let me know if you are interested
Andrew NOLA wrote on SethFitzke's profile.
I have an unfired Ruger 375 African if you are interested. $1,100 shipped to you

Bought it earlier this year

Andrew
504-453-7588
 
Top