I think the animal would take more issue with you cutting off its head and putting it on your wall than with your wife putting a hat on it.So every year for Christmas my wife decorates up the house. Part of her annual ritual is "decorating" my mounted heads. They typically get Santa hats, scarfs, ornaments from the antlers etc. I have always felt inside that it was disrespectful to the animal but I have never said anything to her.
Am I warranted in feeling this way or am I overthinking it?
Honestly, the animal doesn’t care. I suspect you’re the one who feels disrespected because she doesn’t hold “your” mounts in the same esteem as you do. Well, why should she? Do you display other people’s trophies? One day your children or your children’s children will toss them all in a dumpster. Until then, you get to enjoy them your way, and your wife lets you do it 11 months out of the year. Let your wife enjoy them her way for a few weeks. Sharing is caring.