How to choose the “best” safari hunt outfitter

PapaPaint

AH senior member
Joined
Feb 27, 2024
Messages
50
Reaction score
22
Hello. Been a while since I posted.

We have a hunt booked in 2027 with White Lion Safaris (won a Safari raffle). VERY happy with this choice based on everything I’ve researched and in emailing with them.

Some info, then a question….
- I fully intend to do more than one trip to Africa for more hunting.
- I know a lot of people do repeat trips with the same outfitter because of how well their first trip went, and that may very well be where I land.
- For outfitter choices, there’s also word of mouth from family, friends, taxidermists.
- The question: For someone who wants to gather info on a “best” outfitter by area to hunt with, is there such a thing as some sort of an “X stars” rating or a site that rates outfitters?
 
There are way too many definitions of best for it to be that simple. Everyone has different priorities, experience levels, and personalities affecting their opinions. The only way to find the best for you is to decide what you are looking for, research what you want, talk to references, talk to the outfitters, then go on a hunt and use that hunt to better plan your next one. My definition of best changes with each hunt I go on. I enjoy hunting with good outfitters again but I really think it takes hunting with different PHs and outfitters to really understand what best is, if there even is such thing. Outfitters can also lose their good reputations for a variety of reasons. Things can change from one year to the next so you can never assume what was great once still is.
 
There is not any rating site that I’m aware of, but it’s very easy to figure out who the top PH’s are. Just perusing some of the websites will give you a good idea of who long standing top PH’s, companies and areas are. Pay attention to who experienced Africa hunters go with; I’m referring to hunters who’ve been on more than a couple safaris and who’ve hunted multiple countries for a broad variety of game. You’ll figure out who is highly regarded pretty quickly.

I am not in any way denigrating or demeaning South Africa or South African PH’s and safari operators in any way; but Africa is so much more than just South Africa. There are many good people who give good safaris in South Africa. But, if that’s the only place you hunt, you’ve only read one chapter of the wonderful book that is Africa. I always look at African hunting as ‘There is South Africa and there is everywhere else’. Enjoy your South African hunt but don’t be afraid to look beyond afterward.

A proper safari in an unfenced, remote & Wild area is much different than a lodge based hunt on a fenced private game ranch. Each have their own proper attributes but are significantly different experiences.
 
A proper safari in an unfenced, remote & Wild area is much different than a lodge based hunt on a fenced private game ranch. Each have their own proper attributes but are significantly different experiences.
That's very true, but then this comes at a price that is not just monetary. Some areas may not have developed or have amenities as you can expect in SA. Again, this is a question of preference. Some may like the old wild Africa to hunt, while some may go the more traditional route.
 
That's very true, but then this comes at a price that is not just monetary. Some areas may not have developed or have amenities as you can expect in SA. Again, this is a question of preference. Some may like the old wild Africa to hunt, while some may go the more traditional route.
I’ve read it’s not affordable too many times. It seems more of a mindset than a fact. Most hunters looking for a PG hunt are happy with ranch land and just aren’t looking elsewhere. Here is one offer. I know of others at comparable pricing.
 
That's very true, but then this comes at a price that is not just monetary. Some areas may not have developed or have amenities as you can expect in SA. Again, this is a question of preference. Some may like the old wild Africa to hunt, while some may go the more traditional route.
The traditional route is what you describe as “old wild Africa”. If you go back to the period before 1990 or so, most African hunting was ‘Old & Wild’.

The rise of the South African safari industry is mostly since around 1985 and after. There were some very good South African operations and PH’s before then, but a small fraction of present day South African safari hunting.
 
The traditional route is what you describe as “old wild Africa”. If you go back to the period before 1990 or so, most African hunting was ‘Old & Wild’.

The rise of the South African safari industry is mostly since around 1985 and after. There were some very good South African operations and PH’s before then, but a small fraction of present day South African safari hunting.
Well said Sir, PM me if you know of anyone still around in SA
 
Hello. Been a while since I posted.

We have a hunt booked in 2027 with White Lion Safaris (won a Safari raffle). VERY happy with this choice based on everything I’ve researched and in emailing with them.

Some info, then a question….
- I fully intend to do more than one trip to Africa for more hunting.
- I know a lot of people do repeat trips with the same outfitter because of how well their first trip went, and that may very well be where I land.
- For outfitter choices, there’s also word of mouth from family, friends, taxidermists.
- The question: For someone who wants to gather info on a “best” outfitter by area to hunt with, is there such a thing as some sort of an “X stars” rating or a site that rates outfitters?

There isn't a specific rating system or site you can look at. Far too many outfitters to consider. I have no way to really verify but I've herd the number thrown around a couple times that in South Africa alone there are close to 7000 Outfitters and 4-5 times that number of licensed PH's. How many are active is probably less. A country like Zimbabwe you're probably looking at 75-100ish Registered Outfitters and significantly less active 50-65 (my guess).

One way to get an idea of good outfitters is to look at some of the "Endorsed Outfitters". I know Craig Boddington has this and believe Jim Shockey has done this in the past. I personally take some of the other "hunting celebrities" with a grain of salt when they suggest someone or something because they're just slinging stuff for whoever gives them the best deal or contract. Look at how many have switched bands.

You can also look at who's been given SCI and DSC Outfitter or PH of the year awards. These are very prestigious and a good indication of who's on the top level. Typically these will also be the same outfitters your regular and top end hunters are booking with. Think guys that spend 30-150 days a year hunting in Africa, ones that hunt multiple Dangerous Game species each year or each safari.

I take this with a grain of salt, but you can also look at social media. Sometimes certain outfitters have a big social media presence and get a lot of attention. I sometimes think some of these guys are struggling and this is another form of advertising for them, especially if they're promoting hunting with certain "celebrities". My personal favorite outfitter is one with no social media, or web presence who's just word of mouth and referral business.

You also might want to look at who's hunting the area, or species you want to hunt. I take this more into account, and try to hunt species where they're naturally occurring and endemic rather than introduced. There are some PH's/Outfitters who are known for chasing specific animals; think leopard guys, lion guys, elephant guys, someone like Buzz with CMS who's known for not only elephants but tuskless at that. If you're just talking the common plains game species it's not as big a deal. This is where area is important. This is where you can also weigh the idea of Wild Africa against the idea of hunting in Africa. There are some great options in South Africa that are free range, or so large they're essentially free range. Crusader Safaris and Coenraad Vermaak are two that come to mind.

Just remember what's important to me, or someone else, might not be as important to you. The last way, and IMO best way is to talk to the outfitters/PH's and their references. WhatsApp, Email, and trade shows like DSC and SCI have made this much easier.


My recommendations
1) Make a list of what species are important to you (this will change many times as you hunt)
2) Make a list of any areas you really want to try and hunt
3) Decide if you care about hunting species in areas where they've been introduced or where they naturally occurred
4) Determine your budget - some countries will be naturally more expensive because of government fees (Tanzania for instance)
5) Book your trip and go hunt
 
I would start with what style of hunt do you want, then narrow down to the country, then research outfits in that county. Africa is huge and every country has something different to offer.
 
There isn't a specific rating system or site you can look at. Far too many outfitters to consider. I have no way to really verify but I've herd the number thrown around a couple times that in South Africa alone there are close to 7000 Outfitters and 4-5 times that number of licensed PH's. How many are active is probably less. A country like Zimbabwe you're probably looking at 75-100ish Registered Outfitters and significantly less active 50-65 (my guess).

One way to get an idea of good outfitters is to look at some of the "Endorsed Outfitters". I know Craig Boddington has this and believe Jim Shockey has done this in the past. I personally take some of the other "hunting celebrities" with a grain of salt when they suggest someone or something because they're just slinging stuff for whoever gives them the best deal or contract. Look at how many have switched bands.

You can also look at who's been given SCI and DSC Outfitter or PH of the year awards. These are very prestigious and a good indication of who's on the top level. Typically these will also be the same outfitters your regular and top end hunters are booking with. Think guys that spend 30-150 days a year hunting in Africa, ones that hunt multiple Dangerous Game species each year or each safari.

I take this with a grain of salt, but you can also look at social media. Sometimes certain outfitters have a big social media presence and get a lot of attention. I sometimes think some of these guys are struggling and this is another form of advertising for them, especially if they're promoting hunting with certain "celebrities". My personal favorite outfitter is one with no social media, or web presence who's just word of mouth and referral business.

You also might want to look at who's hunting the area, or species you want to hunt. I take this more into account, and try to hunt species where they're naturally occurring and endemic rather than introduced. There are some PH's/Outfitters who are known for chasing specific animals; think leopard guys, lion guys, elephant guys, someone like Buzz with CMS who's known for not only elephants but tuskless at that. If you're just talking the common plains game species it's not as big a deal. This is where area is important. This is where you can also weigh the idea of Wild Africa against the idea of hunting in Africa. There are some great options in South Africa that are free range, or so large they're essentially free range. Crusader Safaris and Coenraad Vermaak are two that come to mind.

Just remember what's important to me, or someone else, might not be as important to you. The last way, and IMO best way is to talk to the outfitters/PH's and their references. WhatsApp, Email, and trade shows like DSC and SCI have made this much easier.


My recommendations
1) Make a list of what species are important to you (this will change many times as you hunt)
2) Make a list of any areas you really want to try and hunt
3) Decide if you care about hunting species in areas where they've been introduced or where they naturally occurred
4) Determine your budget - some countries will be naturally more expensive because of government fees (Tanzania for instance)
5) Book your trip and go hunt
THANK YOU, Mtn_Infantry! Excellent response!
 
There are way too many definitions of best for it to be that simple. Everyone has different priorities, experience levels, and personalities affecting their opinions. The only way to find the best for you is to decide what you are looking for, research what you want, talk to references, talk to the outfitters, then go on a hunt and use that hunt to better plan your next one. My definition of best changes with each hunt I go on. I enjoy hunting with good outfitters again but I really think it takes hunting with different PHs and outfitters to really understand what best is, if there even is such thing. Outfitters can also lose their good reputations for a variety of reasons. Things can change from one year to the next so you can never assume what was great once still is.
Thank you, 375Fox! I think you helped me out before with some input and I truly appreciate it.
 
There is not any rating site that I’m aware of, but it’s very easy to figure out who the top PH’s are. Just perusing some of the websites will give you a good idea of who long standing top PH’s, companies and areas are. Pay attention to who experienced Africa hunters go with; I’m referring to hunters who’ve been on more than a couple safaris and who’ve hunted multiple countries for a broad variety of game. You’ll figure out who is highly regarded pretty quickly.

I am not in any way denigrating or demeaning South Africa or South African PH’s and safari operators in any way; but Africa is so much more than just South Africa. There are many good people who give good safaris in South Africa. But, if that’s the only place you hunt, you’ve only read one chapter of the wonderful book that is Africa. I always look at African hunting as ‘There is South Africa and there is everywhere else’. Enjoy your South African hunt but don’t be afraid to look beyond afterward.

A proper safari in an unfenced, remote & Wild area is much different than a lodge based hunt on a fenced private game ranch. Each have their own proper attributes but are significantly different experiences.
Thank you, DLSCR!
 
I’ve read it’s not affordable too many times. It seems more of a mindset than a fact. Most hunters looking for a PG hunt are happy with ranch land and just aren’t looking elsewhere. Here is one offer. I know of others at comparable pricing.
Yeah. I was watching a hunt video and saw a Grant’s Gazelle harvested. BEAUTIFUL animal and I immediately added it to my “someday” list. Then I priced some hunts in Tanzania. Woah!
That will be a few more pennies saved.
 

Forum statistics

Threads
57,728
Messages
1,238,549
Members
101,838
Latest member
BeckyBehre
 

 

 

Latest profile posts

Grz63 wrote on MontanaPat's profile.
hello
I am planning a trip next Sept in MT. May I ask you to tell me if I have forgotten something essential and if something is not worthy. Thank you
Philippe

Billings: little big horn battle field
MT Grizzly encounter
Rockies Museum
Great falls : CM russel museum, Lewis Clark Helena center
horseback riding
Garnet ghost town , Buffalo Range
road to the sun , apgar , hiking in Glacier NP
Anaconda
Bullet Safaris wrote on River Valley's profile.
Hi - welcome to AH!
cheers,
Nathan Askew
 
Top