I love them, others don’t. Perhaps it’s one of options and fit. If you’re 5’10” and 165lbs you have limitless shoe choices and you probably don’t think much about good footwear much.
If you’re 300lbs, nearly 7’, and you wear a 15.5 shoe you care a lot.
I’ve never worn a finer pair of boots. I have two pair and that’s what goes on safari or any dry weather hunt.
Another feature: they don’t smell. If you wear them all day, they smell like clean fresh leather. There is nothing in them to foster microbes and stink like the synthetic fabric junk we buy in the west. I’m sure I have 200 hunting miles on my one pair and they are now perfectly broken in like a great baseball glove. One pair is so broken in I will only wear them hunting so they stay perfectly broken in, 50% used up, forever. The other pair is 30% used up and will be dedicated to hunting only when they hit 50%, forcing me to buy another pair.
I also have two pairs of their casual shoes in hippo and elephant. I wear them with jeans all the time for great all day comfort.
Longwinded way to say I think very highly of them.