who is responsible for the broken skull? late payment and wrong weight has nothing to do with that.
I think Mr. Perez said he got it that way from the outfitter.
I would have thought that once the trophies were crated, no one else would see them until they are opened once they enter North America. I could be wrong on that, given what was said in the emails Robert provided.
I have had something similar happen, but it was caught in time. I had pictures of all my trophies at the end of the particular hunt (something my PH (used multiple times) insists on), and there was a complete skull. When it was being packed, I was advised the skull was in pieces. I advised the taxidermist not to send the broken pieces - I don't need to pay for shipping and duty on something I'm going to throw away. But having the pictures gave me the proof I needed that they fault lay with the outfitter or taxidermist.
Equally, I had taken a lioness and wanted a rug mount. When the mount arrived, all of the claws - every one of them - was missing. Fortunately, I had video of me showing the camera the claws!
Moral of the story - take pictures of what you have, and ask questions every step of the way.
Equally, I suggest taxidermists have an obligation to inform clients when they are packing something which doesn't seem right. Why send a bunch skull fragments?