A thorough conversation with Swarovski - Conclusion: Rookhawk knows nothing and is wrong about everything

We have to accept that as traditionalists we are in a tiny minority. The gun world has moved to long range and tactical. Just look at the size of bolt handles on factory rifles.

That said I just picked up a Z5i+ and it’s great. Fits on my model 70 in low rings. Doesn’t look quite as good as the 1948 weaver it replaced but doesn’t look out of place either.

Also looking online the Z8+ still has many models with 30mm tubes are those all going away?
 
To see such heresy in the hallowed pages of our favourite forum.... Next you will be attacking Blaser rifles!

The optics world seems to have gone into fashion rather than function. And the current fashion is long range shooting complete with high bc bullets, new long range cartridges etc. I wonder at the wisdom when a company throws all it eggs into the long range basket and neglects the market that gave it life but what do I know. As others have said, the long range market doesn't seem excited by their scopes. I don't think they have got it right. Maybe, like Nikon, they want to dump hunting and say they are just target oriented. Less stress that way.
 
You can always tell a German. Or Austrian. But you can’t tell him much.

Unfortunately, The tactical world is 1000 fold larger than the DG niche
Exactly right. This is why we won't get what we want but many others will get what they want. If only Swaro would have a little skunk works division and build some classic optics with modern glass, they would sell all of them. It wouldn't be their biggest market but it would be successful.
 
Indeed. If they'd make a single EE (the z8i 30mm with the illuminated circle/#4 combo would be logical) and a 3-9x36mm with a #4, they would have a solution in those two SKUs for 90% of the use cases presented on this forum. Both of these options have no industry competition, suggesting 100% of the demand would be satisfied by Swarovski rather than the entire market vying for a customer.
Not that anyone at Swaro cares what I think...I just own 8 or 10 of their scopes...but if these 2 were available, I would have one or the other on almost every rifle I hunt with.
 
Exactly right. This is why we won't get what we want but many others will get what they want. If only Swaro would have a little skunk works division and build some classic optics with modern glass, they would sell all of them. It wouldn't be their biggest market but it would be successful.

I have to wonder what the ROI would be though… or what price point you’d have to sell at to realize a reasonable ROI…

I don’t see the problem being swaro… I see the problem being the market…

Simple truth is hunting is a sport in decline while shooting sports are in a rapid upswing…

Swaro is simply responding to the market…

If we assume they’d immediately sell out of 3000 EE optics every year as soon as they came off the assembly line… a lot of that is going to depend on price (no matter how badly I might want an EE scope, the number of people willing to pay $6-$10k for one is going to be extremely limited)…

So how much does it cost to build the facility, purchase the tooling, train the staff, pay the staff, etc to man the skunk works? And what’s the cost of marketing to a shrinking consumer group? And how much time is left before that consumer group gets so small that it’s not worth servicing any longer?

My fear is we are likely already there…

If swaro believed there was a good return on servicing the DG hunting community, they’d be doing it..

The reality is even the typical deer hunter these days thinks he needs (wants) a 20x capable optic with at least a 50mm bell..

So they’re giving the market what the market demands..
 
[emoji6]" data-quote="PHOENIX PHIL" data-source="post: 0" class="bbCodeBlock bbCodeBlock--expandable bbCodeBlock--quote js-expandWatch">
Or more like they're going make what the guys doing the market analysis say to make.

No this was one of those guys. He basically said that they don’t listen to them.
 
Let’s not forget that the sporting optics business is a drop in the bucket for Swarovski. Their revenue of over 2 billion euros is quite healthy. Sport optics is less than 200 million euro.
 
I am in the same mind set as @rookhawk .

My beef is that and after the z3 scope failed on my wife's 7RM on our 2022 safari. I sent the scope back in for repair and it came back and within 3 shots failed again. Took it off and sat in the box and put it on the shelf in the shop about 3 months ago on a less than optimum day I took it back out and looked at it, bashed the bell against the work bench and threw it in the trash. It might have just been a lemon as the other Swaro glass we have is doing great. But will but something else till they turn around their offerings.

The other small item if you look at the top 200 PRS shooters not one of them are using Swaro's. Kahles has about 11% of the field.

I’m not in the PRS game, my long range work happens in the back 40. However, I suspect that Nightforce and Leupold are well represented in this game.
 
Indeed. If they'd make a single EE (the z8i 30mm with the illuminated circle/#4 combo would be logical) and a 3-9x36mm with a #4, they would have a solution in those two SKUs for 90% of the use cases presented on this forum. Both of these options have no industry competition, suggesting 100% of the demand would be satisfied by Swarovski rather than the entire market vying for a customer.

And if they could give that three to nine a solid four inches of eye relief they would have solved the number one conundrum.
 
Glad I picked up the three Z8i's when I did. Thinking about grabbing another Z8i 1-8x24 from a friend who's wanting something else.
 
@rookhawk
Great topic! thanks for sharing!
Now the main question is: which scope brands would you recommend to look at, to suit the needs of the traditional hunter that you described?
 
I hate that missed out on the small bell z’s… I own .. but would love to have more…

I diligently watch for them on auctions… I got lucky with my second one and picked it up for $[emoji[emoji6][emoji6]][emoji[emoji6][emoji6]]… haven’t seen one go for less than double that since… and they don’t come up often..
 
Glad I picked up the three Z8i's when I did. Thinking about grabbing another Z8i 1-8x24 from a friend who's wanting something else.
Do it!
 
You can always reroute to the "frugal" path. :D I just bought a new set of rings, base, and scope for $250 all in and it works great. Would that setup look right on a $400,000 gun? Maybe not, but I wouldn't look right holding one of those guns either. My setup will kill buffalo just fine.
 
The hard part of this millennials trend is finding scopes that aren't flat matte finish. Seems hunting guns are headed back to WWI parkerized trench warfare look after working so hard to evolve away from it. Sigh!
 
Last weekend I had a lengthy conversation with the region's swarovksi rep and we talked about a lot of different things, but basically the summary was nothing I want is available and they have no intention of making more of what I deemed fantastic. A few of the highlights of the conversation:

1.) My premise: The z6i 1-6x24mm EE was the finest optic ever made. They are selling for 200%-300% of original MSRP new in the box. Swarovski's position is nobody wanted them and they lose FOV, they believe FOV is the key trait. They stated "how much eye relief do you really need anyway?". My response was two fold, one that 5" allows you to scope large bore rifles and its literally the only one that exists. I don't enjoy close scopes on 458Lott and up rifles. My second point was that for stalking rifles, it gave the opportunity to come up for a snap shot like a shotgun, rather than seeking for good eye relief that introduces hesitation. They politely disagreed. They said if I bought 1500 of them, roughly $3.3m USD, they'd make me anything I want. I asked for a practical number minimum order and I'd maybe do just that, but they wouldn't give me a reasonable number. They did mention they sold some sort of rail mount scope in the USA and literally sold 4 units of them, but they didn't want to make another EE.

2.) My second topic was that the 3-9x36mm z3 was a bargain and perfect for stalking rifles at <$700 for a great optic. The weight and size allowed low rings and was appropriate for kipplaufs, falling blocks, and lightweight bolt guns. Their response was the 42mm is barely bigger, so they are just sticking with that one.

3.) My third point was that we were standing next to a rack of London made safari rifles worth about $400,000. For those rifles, people take pride in traditional rings and a low or extra low ring that brings the sight picture in line with the stock geometry and iron sights. That means a scope like the z8i 1-8x24mm with the 30mm tube should be brought back, because aesthetically and functionally people spending premium money on safari and stalking rifles do not want 34mm rings, nor do they want the extra height, nor do they want to use hideously ugly tactical rings. You really have very few options in fine gun rings in 34mm whereas there is a plethora of rings for the 1" and 30mm offerings that are appropriate for Rigbys, Dakotas, and all the other typical safari rifles. Swarovski's answer was that I should just buy ugly 34mm rings, or I could pay $5500-$8000 and have someone like Rigby or Holland build new custom 34mm rings and mounts to accomodate their new tube sizes rather than offering an industry standard 30mm scope appropriate for the task. Another lovely scope option now discontinued.

4.) My fourth question was "what happened to the Kahles Helia lineup?" because they had nice small bells for stalking rifles, or they had straight tube 4x and 5x options for double rifles, drillings, kipplaufs, etc. Their response was they are still made for the EU market because Vortex and Leupold do not have a presence, but they are no longer imported to the USA. I asked if I bought them in the EU, would they support them for repairs? The answer is no, it would be deemed gray market.

I'm being told that the market doesn't demand what I like and that I'm in the minority. Maybe that's correct, but Swarovski also spent decades building a reputation as a true hunter's optic company. The brochures would show old gentleman hunting chamois with kipplaufs, trachten jackets, tyrollian hats on their heads. It suggested quality and tradition, that was their reputation. They no longer make the products that are compatible with the lifestyles and firearms they loved to feature in their ad copy of the past ten years, now showing bench rest plastic rifles and gigantic glass in their ad copy.

I suggested they cannibalized their own market, too many SKUs, reticles, illuminations, and that dilution resulted in too few units sold of these storied products. They also didn't offer the lineup above to the right dealers, the bespoke makers and the Dakota/Rigby/et al dealers that know how to use the right rings, mounts, and optics for the tasks at hand. They remained unpersuaded and closed the conversation showing me their new Western Hunter long-range scope with ballistic turrets for shooting elk at 700 yards. Clearly, they are selling into the sniper and long range hunter industry where every other brand has a large presence as well.

I'm not here to shoot the messenger, Swarovski has the right to do whatever they wish, I'm just saddened that the best optic company in the world has discontinued 100% of the optics that I have come to love over the past 20 years. I honestly think part of the problem is most dealers in fine rifles don't even understand stock-to-optic fit so they aren't advocating for what is proper and correct for their rifles either.

Any way you slice it, Swarovski has products that are now directly in line with Vortex, Leupold, and Nightforce but none of the useful outliers that they were known for over the past many decades.

When you, the manufacturer, are being told by the representatives of their largest market, that they are moving in the wrong direction..

Only the Europeans could be arrogant enough to tell you that you are wrong

Bless them
 
Last edited:
So, what I just learned is that I'm really glad I bought my 1-6X24EE when I did, for the price I paid, even though it didn't work for what I thought it would. And I'm not selling it for anything.

Also, as has been stated, "precision rifle shooting" has become a large part of the market, while we hunters retain a small part, and, especially in Germany/Austria, despite the wonderful marketing, is becoming smaller. This is why you can buy fine German rifles for such a reasonable price. Older hunters move to the Happy Hunting Grounds, and their heirs by law need to either sell the rifles, or have them destroyed/rendered incapable of use. That's the modern world in which we live.

Who the hell wants to shoot an elk at 700m? Get closer.

Second thought: Optics are not rocket surgery. I mean, we know what works, and we can probably buy high quality glass, right? So why don't we, as a group, invest some of our hard earned cash and create a company that assembles/manufactures the scopes that we want/need? I don't have a large amount of free cash, but I understand logistics and distribution, and I'm willing to invest my time. Who's with me? It's a niche/vertical market, but what do we need to make it work?
 
We have to accept that as traditionalists we are in a tiny minority. The gun world has moved to long range and tactical. Just look at the size of bolt handles on factory rifles.

That said I just picked up a Z5i+ and it’s great. Fits on my model 70 in low rings. Doesn’t look quite as good as the 1948 weaver it replaced but doesn’t look out of place either.

Also looking online the Z8+ still has many models with 30mm tubes are those all going away?

Yeah, what IS with the size of bolt handles? Do the majority of shooters have some sort of degenerative nerve function disease??
 
  • Like
Reactions: WAB

Forum statistics

Threads
59,294
Messages
1,284,871
Members
107,451
Latest member
NadiaWhitm
 

 

 

Latest profile posts

CamoManJ wrote on dchum's profile.
Hello there. I’ve been wanting to introduce myself personally & chat with you about hunting Nilgai. Give me a call sometime…

Best,

Jason Coryell
[redacted]
VonJager wrote on Mauser3000's profile.
+1 Great to deal with. I purchased custom rifle. No issues.
ghay wrote on Buckums's profile.
I saw you were looking for some Swift A-Frames for your 9.3. I just bought a bulk supply of them in the 285g. version. If Toby's are gone, I could let 100 go for $200 shipped you are interested.
Thanks,
Gary
Ferhipo wrote on Bowhuntr64's profile.
I am really fan of you
Bighorn191 wrote on Mtn_Infantry's profile.
Booked with Harold Grinde - Gana River - they sure kill some good ones - who'd you get set up with?
 
Top