I agree with everyone. Without more info, pic's of exit wounds, internal damage, etc., no way to know what they were doing. I guess it's possible to get a bad "lot" but not probable. I've been shooting Noslers for almost thirty years and have never had a failure due to the bullet. I've been using the 160gr Accubond's in a 7 Rem Mag since it's inception. All with expected performance results. I have quite a few recovered bullets. All held together, mushroomed to twice the original diameter and retained 65-70 percent of their original weight. Those not recovered left devistating wound channels. The only thing I can think happened is the bonding process failed and allowed the lead core to separate from the copper jacket upon impact. Not likely, but possible. I quit using Sierra bullets years ago because of that occurrence. We're these bullets " factory seconds"? Did you find any evidence of pieces of copper jackets in any wound channels? Was there the normal large area of hydrostatic shock in the wound area after skinning? This is a very odd occurrence for Nosler. Wish I could have been in the skinning shed.... Lol