.458 WM, Huh???

hoytcanon

AH fanatic
Joined
Jan 22, 2024
Messages
761
Reaction score
1,972
Location
Ontario, Canada
Media
36
Hunting reports
Africa
1
Howdy AH Reloading folk,

I have been reloading for decades and for .458 WM for most of that time for many rifles. I have a standard load of 75.0 H335 with 500 RN's @ 3.340" that works perfectly in my current Carbine. I am in the process of developing a somewhat reduced load, for the spring bear season, utilizing the Barnes original .458 400 grain SP using H4895. With a target speed of 2000 fps, I calculated approximately 64 grains and loaded to 3.300". My first test load was cycled in the rifle, but upon ejection the bullet stayed in the leade and the cartridge ejected, dumping the powder in the action. I thought that maybe I screwed up the OAL, so I remeasured three rounds, and after punching out the stuck bullet, attempted to cycle a round from the magazine... same thing happened. I then punched the bullet, removed the rounds in the mag and reduced the OAL to 3.250"... same thing happened again... jammed bullet, dumped powder... I pushed the bullet, cleaned the action reduced another round to 3.200" and tried again, this time it fed and cycled properly and smoothly.

Here is my question, maybe someone has the answer? If the 500 RN at 3.340" feeds and ejects perfectly, how is it that the 400 SP has to be reduced to 3.200" in order to feed and eject??? See picture below. Any and all comments welcome.

20250126_135232.jpg
 
At what point are the bullets the exact same diameter? I had an issue with Swift 300gr bullets in my 9.3 - they would get stuck. I took each of the bullets i was testing for feeding, stuck them in the muzzle and drew a line. here are the results from L-R:
Barnes 250 TSX, Swift 300, North Fork 286, Woodleigh 286, Woodleigh 250, North Fork 286 (Cup Point), Barnes 286.

It solved that mystery real quick.

AFrames.JPG
 
Make some dummy rounds using both projectiles. Coat them with a sharpie from crimp forward and then chamber each, you’ll find your answer. O Gives are different.
 
Make some dummy rounds using both projectiles. Coat them with a sharpie from crimp forward and then chamber each, you’ll find your answer. O Gives are different.

I just realized what I did when I compared the ogives as being the same... I compared the 500 RN to the 400 SP "AFTER" I had shortened them to 3.200" not to the 400 SP at 3.300"... when I did that the problem was apparent. Age and haste create many problems for reloaders! Lol
 
You need to measure base to ogive.

Use the correct diameter insert and lock onto calipers. Very easy to use and helpful when swapping bullets as you are doing.

 

Attachments

Each bullet has a different ogive profile, and therefore will contact the lands at a different OAL.

Yes, of course, I measured the OAL to the ogive, but this was after the stuck bullet episodes as the SP "appeared" to have the ogive set further back than the RN, but when I measured, I used one of the bullets that I had already shortened by mistake and everything checked out, causing my confusion. I realized what I had done when I went to press the remaining bullets from 3.300" to 3.200".

Fraught for naught... lol.
 

Forum statistics

Threads
60,547
Messages
1,320,318
Members
111,821
Latest member
JohnieMcSh
 

 

 

Latest profile posts

Safari Dave wrote on GUN & TROPHY INSURANCE's profile.
I have been using a "Personal Property" rider on my State Farm homeowner's policy to cover guns when I travel with them.
I have several firearms, but only one is worth over $20K (A Heym double rifle).
Very interested.
Would firearms be covered for damage, as well as, complete loss?
I'll can let the State Farm rider cover my watches...
Behind the scenes of taking that perfect picture.....






WhatsApp Image 2025-04-23 at 09.58.07.jpeg
krokodil42 wrote on Jager Waffen74's profile.
Good Evening Evert One.
Would like to purchase 16 Ga 2.50 ammo !!
Rattler1 wrote on trperk1's profile.
trperk1, I bought the Kimber Caprivi 375 back in an earlier post. You attached a target with an impressive three rounds touching 100 yards. I took the 2x10 VX5 off and put a VX6 HD Gen 2 1x6x24 Duplex Firedot on the rifle. It's definitely a shooter curious what loads you used for the group. Loving this rifle so fun to shoot. Africa 2026 Mozambique. Buff and PG. Any info appreciated.
Ready for the hunt with HTK Safaris
 
Top