I am a big fan of AR owners learning to fully assemble an AR at least once. It gives you a much better understanding of how your rifle functions, and equips you with the knowledge to swap out just about any part in the event of a breakage. Of course, you could do this just as well by disassembling an off-the-shelf AR, then re-assembling it (same net effect).
If you go the build-it-yourself route, I have had very good luck with Ballistic Advantage barrels. I have two of the 16" fluted stainless barrels in 223 Wylde, and an 18" in the same caliber; all three are easily sub-MOA right out of the box. Their 1:8 twist does well stabilizing the 55gr bullets, but really starts to shine in the 68-77 grain range. Side note: the AAC brand of ammo from Palmetto State is one of the best kept secrets on the market. ;-)
As far as off-the-shelf AR's go, I have them from Smith & Wesson, Wyndham, ArmaLite, and even some High Standards. All function very well, and seem to be pretty accurate. The ArmaLite in particular is their heavy-barreled version with a 24" stainless Lothar-Walther barrel in a 1:8 twist; and not surprisingly, it is an absolute tack-driver. Along with Sig, Daniel Defense, and Christensen; I don't think you can go wrong with just about any of the good quality makers available nowadays. Even if you get a problematic one, most problems can be solved by the swapping of just one component.
PS - I'll add my +1 to the importance of a great trigger. A good barrel and a good trigger will make for all the difference in the world with an AR.
If you go the build-it-yourself route, I have had very good luck with Ballistic Advantage barrels. I have two of the 16" fluted stainless barrels in 223 Wylde, and an 18" in the same caliber; all three are easily sub-MOA right out of the box. Their 1:8 twist does well stabilizing the 55gr bullets, but really starts to shine in the 68-77 grain range. Side note: the AAC brand of ammo from Palmetto State is one of the best kept secrets on the market. ;-)
As far as off-the-shelf AR's go, I have them from Smith & Wesson, Wyndham, ArmaLite, and even some High Standards. All function very well, and seem to be pretty accurate. The ArmaLite in particular is their heavy-barreled version with a 24" stainless Lothar-Walther barrel in a 1:8 twist; and not surprisingly, it is an absolute tack-driver. Along with Sig, Daniel Defense, and Christensen; I don't think you can go wrong with just about any of the good quality makers available nowadays. Even if you get a problematic one, most problems can be solved by the swapping of just one component.
PS - I'll add my +1 to the importance of a great trigger. A good barrel and a good trigger will make for all the difference in the world with an AR.