Most Overrated Hunt and Most Underrated Hunt

Had a friend and a group of guys with the USFWS that would always go to Minnesota in October for grouse and woodcock. They usually did pretty well up until my buddy having a massive heart attack and died. The only way they found him was his dogs beeper collar lead them to him. The dog wouldn’t leave his side.
 
Most overrated for me would be Stone/Dall sheep hunting.
Most underrated would be Kodiak Island Brown Bear hunting
@Slickshooter - OK, you got my attention with your post…I’ve NEVER heard anyone describe a “Kodiak Brown Bear Hunt” as UNDER rated ! How could a hunt for the Largest Bears on the Planet (along with the Upper Peninsula) be “UNDER rated”? They are way Over Priced and usually Overly WET, but never Never UNDER rated…..even guys that failed to get their Bear raved about the size & numbers of bear seen and taken by others on Kodiak….at least the Hunters that I’ve spoken with that have gone. I could see some saying it’s “Over rated” because they went expecting an 11 foot - 1500lb bear and “Only” took a 9 footer/850 lbs. !!
 
Had a friend and a group of guys with the USFWS that would always go to Minnesota in October for grouse and woodcock. They usually did pretty well up until my buddy having a massive heart attack and died. The only way they found him was his dogs beeper collar lead them to him. The dog wouldn’t leave his side.

Man, that is incredibly sad.
 
@Slickshooter - OK, you got my attention with your post…I’ve NEVER heard anyone describe a “Kodiak Brown Bear Hunt” as UNDER rated ! How could a hunt for the Largest Bears on the Planet (along with the Upper Peninsula) be “UNDER rated”? They are way Over Priced and usually Overly WET, but never Never UNDER rated…..even guys that failed to get their Bear raved about the size & numbers of bear seen and taken by others on Kodiak….at least the Hunters that I’ve spoken with that have gone. I could see some saying it’s “Over rated” because they went expecting an 11 foot - 1500lb bear and “Only” took a 9 footer/850 lbs. !!

Or the guy that arrives in camp waits for the next day and walks out into a sunshiny day and shoots a 10 footer!
 
Or the guy that arrives in camp waits for the next day and walks out into a sunshiny day and shoots a 10 footer!
Exactly. My nephew shot a nice ten point white tail his first time out. Too easy-peasy. It was the worst thing that could have happened to him--he quit hunting!
 
@Slickshooter - OK, you got my attention with your post…I’ve NEVER heard anyone describe a “Kodiak Brown Bear Hunt” as UNDER rated ! How could a hunt for the Largest Bears on the Planet (along with the Upper Peninsula) be “UNDER rated”? They are way Over Priced and usually Overly WET, but never Never UNDER rated…..even guys that failed to get their Bear raved about the size & numbers of bear seen and taken by others on Kodiak….at least the Hunters that I’ve spoken with that have gone. I could see some saying it’s “Over rated” because they went expecting an 11 foot - 1500lb bear and “Only” took a 9 footer/850 lbs. !!
Alaska brown bear hunts are certainly over sold. Everybody can get you a 10+ ft bear, right up till you get there.
 
Alaska brown bear hunts are certainly over sold. Everybody can get you a 10+ ft bear, right up till you get there.
I can't recall a bear guide who didn't claim to take 10 footers. There are a few taken each season but it's not normal or average. Guaranteed there are many guides who haven't taken a 10 footer and in interior units, you won't find them. When's the last time you saw a legit 10' bear in a trophy room? Most of them look to be 8 or 9 feet, which is much more typical in the wild. There are a few bear guides working coastal regions with big salmon runs and that's where the big boys are. You're not going to find a 10 footer in a mountain grizzly region, which is the majority of what is taken each year. It takes genetics and a lot of groceries to get that big.
 
@Slickshooter - OK, you got my attention with your post…I’ve NEVER heard anyone describe a “Kodiak Brown Bear Hunt” as UNDER rated ! How could a hunt for the Largest Bears on the Planet (along with the Upper Peninsula) be “UNDER rated”? They are way Over Priced and usually Overly WET, but never Never UNDER rated…..even guys that failed to get their Bear raved about the size & numbers of bear seen and taken by others on Kodiak….at least the Hunters that I’ve spoken with that have gone. I could see some saying it’s “Over rated” because they went expecting an 11 foot - 1500lb bear and “Only” took a 9 footer/850 lbs. !!
Have you hunted brown bears? It’s a lot of idle time glassing. Getting a big bear is a great trophy and accomplishment, but the hunting isn’t for everyone. I can see why someone would call it overrated. I also believe Kodiak is relatively small areas compared to areas on the peninsula.
 
I can't recall a bear guide who didn't claim to take 10 footers. There are a few taken each season but it's not normal or average. Guaranteed there are many guides who haven't taken a 10 footer and in interior units, you won't find them. When's the last time you saw a legit 10' bear in a trophy room? Most of them look to be 8 or 9 feet, which is much more typical in the wild. There are a few bear guides working coastal regions with big salmon runs and that's where the big boys are. You're not going to find a 10 footer in a mountain grizzly region, which is the majority of what is taken each year. It takes genetics and a lot of groceries to get that big.
Everybody wants that 10’er. Then loose their mind when it gets cut I half so it can get packed out. I had to pack out a 9’er w/skull attached and it augered me into the ground. Way harder to pack out than moose hind quarters IMO.
 
I would concede that whitetail CAN be overrated.. but I think that really depends on what someone is looking to get out of the hunt.. its certainly not challenging if thats the primary qualifier..

I genuinely love whitetail hunting though.. not for the trigger pull.. thats pretty easy to accomplish when using a rifle thats rested on pack or some other object, in the window sill of a blind, thats exactly 100 yards from the feeder that the deer has come into to get his morning breakfast..

What I love about whitetail hunting is the peace and quiet.. just sitting in the blind a half hour before sun up, listening to the birds start to wake and move around, watching the squirrels and cardinals steal a few bites of corn every few minutes, while sipping strong coffee from a thermos.. no one else talking to me.. no one else to worry or be concerned about.. phone off.... total calm... I enjoy watching the deer come in, watching their behaviors, etc.. and then after the morning hunt, spending some time in camp with friends, having a nice lunch, bullshitting around, etc... same thing after the afternoon hunt.. hanging out around the fire with buddies, and just enjoying not being in the office.. the trigger pull is just about filling the freezer for me to be honest.. I go deer hunting for all of the other reasons..
Sitting in a boat with a worm on the end of the hook can be just as rewarding for inner peace achievement. I do not classify shooting anything from a shack over bait as hunting. Try stalking whitetail. Just as challenging as stalking buffalo or kudu. Mule deer not so much.
 
Everybody wants that 10’er. Then loose their mind when it gets cut I half so it can get packed out. I had to pack out a 9’er w/skull attached and it augered me into the ground. Way harder to pack out than moose hind quarters IMO.
I've thought a lot about that. Any estimates on what a green, wet hide weighs with skull attached? It's heavy!
 
I've thought a lot about that. Any estimates on what a green, wet hide weighs with skull attached? It's heavy!
No idea, dude. If I had to guess..? Just a few ounces less than the port side anchor of the battleship New Jersey. I was so spent and crippled when I got it off my back in camp I never put it on the delier (spring scale).
 
I can't think of a better way to go. Dying in the woods with my dog by my side.
Yes sir, the only problem would be they would’ve had to shoot my dogs to recover my carcass. They were protective to a fault!!! Chesapeake Bay retrievers!
 
Hmmmm. I don't really know how to answer the OPs question, but I've enjoyed a few hunts more than I thought I would:

Mountain zebra - wary, tough, excellent vision, nasty habitat. Really fun stalks and hunts.

Elephant. Underrated, if that's even possible. Everyone dreams of this. Me too, and I had the completely unexpected opportunity to add on a cancellation exportable elephant to a Caprivi buffalo hunt. I knew it would be fun, and I knew it would be exciting, but it was so unbelievable I can still remember every detail years later. Got it done the evening of the last day. Was sad to miss the disassembly. Pursuing these is so very different than any other type of hunt.

Overrated - I dunno. Even a bad day in the field is better than a day in the office. Besides, bad hunts help you recognize and enjoy the good ones.
 
I would advise saving those grouse outfitter dollars for pheasant adventures instead. But buy a good dog first. We have lots of grouse up here in NW Ontario but I don't bother with them much. Save my dollars for Montana. Lots of Huns and sharptail available there too. And the abundance of state, federal, and publicly accessible private land really makes having a guide unnecessary. I have never been on a guided canned hunt group shoot in South Dakota and know I never will. Once you've spent a week hunting pheasants solo over a good dog, it's hard to be satisfied with anything else. Don't know what heaven will be like but hard to believe it will top that. Those big smart gawdy noisy things jumping up still makes me come unglued every time and I've shot hundreds (probably closer to thousands) of roosters. Hunting pheasants my way is no walk in the park. I usually come back home shy ten or fifteen pounds and the dogs look like they've been starved. Always get a nice buck too. But that never takes more than two days. I'm fine with that. Then I can let the dogs back to work.
 
Most over-rated “hunt”… sitting at a water hole during dry season waiting for a thirsty, stressed animal to come within range.

Most under-rated… tracking eland in the Kalahari behind San trackers.
 
One of the hunts I underrated before doing it was mountain caribou. I did it as an add on when I went after my Dall sheep. Figured if I was already there and just had to pay a trophy fee then that would be a lot better than making a separate trip for one later. It was a fantastic hunt, lots of glassing, great country that was a bit easier to get around in than sheep country, lots of excitement seeing animals and a challenge to plan and make a good stalk. One of the most impressive trophies I have. Also glad I did it when I did since the prices seem to have almost doubled for them since I went in 2021.
 

Forum statistics

Threads
62,387
Messages
1,370,341
Members
119,823
Latest member
Nglidsiles
 

 

 

Latest profile posts

Trusted by First-Time & Repeat African Hunters
Hie Guys . How much are professional hunters earing in Zimbabwe and is it possible to work abroad with your learner professional hunters license
"Ready for the hunt with HTK Safaris!"
cwickgo9 wrote on Bwana Man's profile.
In the pay it forward, I'll take those 38 S&W brass and bullets. I have a .38 Webley that will love something to eat
Nevada Mike wrote on cash_tx's profile.
308 Norma FL die... Please send to me at:

[redacted]

Again, thanks. I I can do something for you I certainly will.

[redacted]
 
Top