The Gaur Shikar Which Went Very Terribly Wrong

Kawshik Rahman

AH elite
Joined
Sep 19, 2019
Messages
1,153
Reaction score
2,497
Media
94
Articles
25
Considering how well received my previous account about hunting a Royal Bengal tiger was , and the request of a few members to give an account of a Gaur Shikar , it is my privilege to oblige. I prefer keeping these accounts to moderate length so as not to bore readers.
Here , l will relate the account of one of my more unforgettable Shikar experiences with Gaur. However , it remains unforgettable for all the wrong reasons. This is the story of the Gaur Shikar which went horribly wrong .
It was 1966 in Darjeeling , India . I had gone to the fire arms shop of Sundar Raj . He had acquired a few 12 bore cartridges from an American client who had discarded them after they were left over from a successful goose shooting event. Mr. Raj was selling them very cheaply at only 5 paise per cartridge . I wondered why he would sell them at such frugal prices , especially as Imported arms and ammunition was nearly impossible to get ahold of. Upon reaching shop , the answer was evident . The cartridges had a 76 millimeter length and no Indian shot-guns in Darjeeling at the time had Chambers safe enough to take anything larger than the 70 millimeter cartridge . There was a solution to this problem but not a very ideal one. There used to be a Tamil gun smith who's son worked at a chauffeur for my father's model T Ford family car. He had a devised a method to cut 70 millimeter cartridge hulls down to 65 millimeter some how and would often provide my father with cartridge cases to use in his I Hollis 12 bore side by side shot-guns which took the 65 millimeter cartridge. Therefore , l purchased all of the nine cartridge cases which Sundar Raj had for sale , hoping that the Tamil gun smith would be able to cut the hull of these cartridges down to 70 millimeter length ( whether this would go on to work is a story for another day ) .
It was then , that Mr. Raj told me that he had a new client for us who had come from the United States of America. An Italian American gentleman who was an author of an American gun magazine book . This gentleman wanted to shoot a variety of species , comprising of the following : A porcupine , a boar , a barking deer and a large Gaur. We had agreed to meet the client at the Darjeeling Circuit house .
The following day we met the gentleman whom we were supposed to guide. He was a large , powerful looking man .He seemed quite well read on fire arms and we were eager to see what fire arms he had brought for his intended quarry. India's old fire arms laws for travellers were identical to the current laws of Bangladesh . A foreign hunter was allowed to bring two fire arms into the country and 250 cartridges for each fire arm ( perhaps , in the future , l should do another article on what clients used to bring ? ) . However , this great man brought only one rifle with him. It was a big rifle of bolt configuration made by the firm , Birmingham Small Arms . It was of calibre magnum .458 Winchester , the first l had ever seen . Along with this , he brought several boxes of brand new ammunition from the American firm , Hornady. There were soft nose bullets and bullets with a metal envelope with a slightly flat nose weighing 500 grains . It looked very big and powerful . However , Karim looked at the cartridges and said " Shahib ( sir ) , may l ask a question ? " . The client responded in the affirmative. Karim asked " Shahib , the magnum .375 cartridge is loaded with a lighter bullet of 300 grains , but it has a larger cartridge size to keep a larger charge of powder . If these bullets in your gun weigh 200 grains more , then should the cartridge size not be larger to accommodate a corresponding charge of powder . Why is it smaller than the magnum .375 ? " . The client confidently assured us that the latest powders used in these cartridges did not need large cases.
The gentleman was clearly a professional with fire arms and we were both quickly convinced of his prowess with the magnum .458 Winchester . He was even kind enough to let me shoot it four times at glass gool ( a local alcohol drink ) bottles which were empty . It certainly seemed powerful enough.
We were thus ready for the week. Being two eager young men excited to see what this big rifle would do to game , we were naturally filled with thrill. If only that big rifle were as good as it were big.
The picture was of me , Karim , the employees at Sundar Raj's shop , Sundar Raj's son , Abhijit ( wearing the sun glasses ) and our Italian American Client who is not wearing a shirt and has a cigarette in his mouth . I am on the right side , holding my 12 bore Ishapore side by side shot-gun. Karim holds the client's magnum .458 Winchester calibre rifle right beneath me . Our chokra ( clerk boy ) , Vivek is standing to the left of our client , holding Karim's .22 Long Rifle BRNO auto loader . The man sitting on the far left is Rumesh , a shop employee who is holding an Ishapore .315 bore bolt operation rifle which he took from the shop to pose for the photograph. This would end up being our first and last pleasant moment for that entire week , as my next post will relate.


full
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Look forward to hearing the rest gaur are an impressive animal. What a life you must have lived!

When you say Bangladesh's current laws, does that mean that hunting by foreigners still is possible there?
 
The client wanted a porcupine creature . Thus , we appointed our local Garo trackers to aid us. Kurraba , Goutam and Sacchin were our favorites . They were soon able to locate a large porcupine near the Kushka hills where these creatures could often be found. Why this gentleman would want to shoot a porcupine with a big rifle created for shooting elephants , is beyond me. Perhaps he wished to test some theory . Perhaps , he wished to accomplish something which the average hunter does not. I cannot say. We did not ask him either at that time , because in Old India the saying was that client is king.

With both me and Karim at his side , the client readied his magnum .458 Winchester calibre Rifle . He had attached a telescopic sight to the rifle. We were looking at the creature from a pair of binoculars which Karim had brought. Our client was 70 yards or so , away from the animal . He pulled the trigger . A deafening crack echoed , but the 500 or 510 grain soft nosed bullet missed the porcupine by quite a large margin. This is natural. A rifle meant for shooting elephants at close distances is not meant for shooting small creatures at greater distances . Fortunately , the porcupine was unconcerned by the loud noise . We comforted our client , by telling him that it must have been the wind . However , the gentleman did not seem to believe us ( We did not believe ourselves either ) . The client repeated his fusillade of lead for three more shots and it was clear that he was not going to be killing it anytime soon. Finally , Karim offered the client his .22 Long Rifle Brno Auto loader , saying “ Shahib , try this small gun”. Embarrassed , the client took the light .22 Long Rifle auto loader which had a telescopic sight on top and killed that porcupine with a single shot. Karim’s Turkish father , the late Mr. Pamuk Chowdhury helped us to skin the animal , as he had experience with taxidermy. It was not the smoothest of experiences , but it was not a bad Shikar...yet.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
The next day , the client and us decided to try our luck with a boar . This time ,we were starting to develop certain seeds of doubt in our mind about the client’s choice of rifle. However , client is king . Finding boars in Darjeeling was not hard.you could find considerable quantities of them in the town outskirts . You do not even need trackers to find them. Therefore , it was just Karim, myself , the client and Apurbo , our servant who volunteered to help us carry the client’s inventory and to help us cut the boar. It was not long before we found a group of boars near the outskirts. The client readied his magnum .458 Winchester. Karim had his .22 Long Rifle Brno auto loader. A boar is a larger creature than a porcupine and so the client’s chances of missing it seemed minuscule . The client fired that big magnum .458 rifle with a soft nosed bullets of either 500 or 510 grain weight ( the correct weight escapes my memory , although l clearly remember that the client had both ) . The bullet ripped into the animal’s stomach and it squealed in pain before retreating among the other boars. The client operated the bolt on his rifle to get it ready to fire again. However , Karim had had enough. He stopped the client from firing into the group of boars and motioned me to go find the wounded animal and put it out of it’s misery. The blood spills and the tracks were easy enough to follow. I put the animal out of it’s misery with a single SG 12 bore cartridge. The client did not want this boar as he had not shot it. I decided to let Apurbo have the boar , as his family were fond of fire roasted pork with tandoori spices. We now come to the final part of this account involving the Gaur .
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I will not bore readers with details of how the client attempted to use this massive gun to shoot at a barking deer from 80 yards and missed him , driving the animal away in full speed after the bullet hit a tree stump near it. Let us go straight to the incident of the Gaur. Our client’s main desire was a large male Gaur. It would be the ultimate trophy. This time , Karim and l thought that the magnum .458 actually will be an excellent choice for the bison. It is a big bullet and the Gaur is a large size animal. We used our Garo trackers this time to help us single out a large lone male Gaur. These people have a most peculiar method of tracking large animals . I do not know the method used in Africa , but l shall relate the Garo method here. They will follow the spoor of the Gaur . They will find dung of the Gaur and will take their sandal off. Then , they will dip their toes into the Gaur’s dung. Based on how cold or warm the dung is , they will be able to gauge how far the animal might have gone.
But find that Gaur , we did . He was a large animal. Not one worth mentioning in a Guinness book of world records book , but very large . The standard method that we had adopted to get clients to shoot a Gaur , was to get them in a position where they would be able to face the Gaur from the side. Ideally , for my client’s using a magnum .375 rifle , the first shot taken from such a position would be done with a soft nose bullet( With Winchester silver tips being a personal favorite ) with the objective of piercing both lungs . If this was done properly , the beast would go a short distance , coughing blood , before it collapsed and breathed it’s last. Just , in case extra shots were needed , the rifle used to be loaded with solid metal envelope bullets under the first cartridge in the magazine. However , our client was a professional fire arms writer and he felt it would be better to use metal envelope solid bullets for the animal. At this point , Karim and l simply did not wish to argue with this professional gentleman. If this Gaur was taken successfully, then this long week would be over.
The client also did not seem to wait for the animal to be standing perfectly side on . He simply took aim and fired. What happened next , was quite possibly the worst three minutes of that entire week. The animal reacted in pain and charged at our client. The client fired three more shots at the animal but , even though they were all fairly placed between the fore legs , they seemed to do little more than stagger the beast. I immediately fired two barrels of my shot-gun , one after the other , at the neck of the Gaur. It turned it’s rage towards me and charged. An instinctive fear overcame me and l hurriedly leapt aside , and began climbing the nearest tree to avoid the Gaur. By now , the client had re filled the magazine of his rifle with more cartridges and began firing at the Gaur . The animal seemed more infuriated than hurt. He charged at the client , while the client fired three more shots before dropping the rifle , and running away from the animal . I jumped down from the tree , broke open the breech of my gun and hurriedly got the empty cartridge cases out , before putting in two more SG cartridges into the gun and rushing towards the Gaur . It was a macabre picture. The Gaur is chasing the client and l chasing the Gaur. However, all those bullets and the two charges of SG into the Gaur’s neck had begun to take it’s toll on the animal. Karim finally took a shot at the neck of the Gaur from a distance of a mere five feet. The concentrated charge of wax treated SG in it’s throat had finally killed it.
The Epilogue will follow
 
Karim and l had the animal cut open. We were most curious to know why the animal took 7 shots from such a big rifle and did not succumb to it’s wounds. The answer ( and photograph) can be seen in Hoss Delgado’s upcoming book as l promised him that l would not share that picture here , since it deals with bullet selection in depth. However , in short detail : something was very wrong with these bullets. Some of them did not go six inches through. The metal envelopes on these solid bullets were evidently ruptured and the lead interior could be seen coming out . I do not know the exact English word for this circumstance , but the picture will hopefully provide a better example. Was this magnum .458 Winchester a bad calibre ? Did the firm , Hornady mistakenly make a flawed consignment of cartridges? I cannot say. I do know that one of my favorite clients used to own a beautiful double barrel rifle in magnum .458 Winchester built by the firm , Holland and Holland. He certainly had no problems with this rifle for acquiring his Royal Bengal tiger or the three Gaurs which he shot for three seasons inDarjeeling.
What was certain was that my poor client left Darjeeling with only a porcupine as his only puroshkaar ( trophy ) and that animal fell not to his big rifle , but to a small .22 Long Rifle bullet
PS : I am impressed very much by how well informed the forum members here are . Two members actually guessed this client’s identity and personally messaged me their guesses by looking at his photograph. They are correct. It is him .
I also apologize for my cowardly actions when the Gaur charged at me. It is quite a disconcerting experience when such a large and ill tempered animal decides to make you the object of it’s rage.
 
Last edited:
Kawshik the combined knowledge and experience of AH members never ceases to astound me. The fact that they did not publicly disclose the name of the "hunter" involved was no surprise. I've read numerous times about "old" 458 Winchester offerings not being up to par performance wise to say the least. Fortunately that has been corrected.
 
Kawshik the combined knowledge and experience of AH members never ceases to astound me. The fact that they did not publicly disclose the name of the "hunter" involved was no surprise. I've read numerous times about "old" 458 Winchester offerings not being up to par performance wise to say the least. Fortunately that has been corrected.
Shootist43 ,
Someday l want to know why this gentleman wanted to shoot a procupine with a rifle intended for big animals . If this happened today , l am certain that most professional hunters would ask the client what he is thinking. I mean no disrespect to my client. He was an absolute gentleman. Just a little too hard set in his ways.
Now , three people have recognized him already. I should have asked somebody here how to make the face blurry. But he is dead now , so there is no harm either way .
 
A possible answer is that he wanted to get it mounted. Many folks use large bore solids on Duiker to reduce the damage a Taxidermist has to deal with. The fact that he missed, is a whole other issue.
 
A possible answer is that he wanted to get it mounted. Many folks use large bore solids on Duiker to reduce the damage a Taxidermist has to deal with. The fact that he missed, is a whole other issue.
Shootist43 , yes that is a possibility l did not think of. It seemed preposterous at the time.
 
Shootist43 , yes that is a possibility l did not think of. It seemed preposterous at the time.
@Shootist43 has that exactly correct. I hate travelling with multiple rifles, so I tend to use the .375 for everything. For tiny animals like Duiker and Suni, I use .375 solids. They produce a .375 entrance and exit wound and no issues for the taxidermist.

You are the one who should consider a book. A number of professional hunters have written anthologies of their hunting experiences in recent years. Almost nothing has been written about the final years of hunting in India.
 
I prefer keeping these accounts to moderate length so as not to bore readers.

Dear Mr Rahman, Sir,
I believe many will agree that your experience will not bore us. Also, I can say, the longer the better.

Many of us here, have been in theory exploring Africa and India (before their first international hunt) through literary works of old hands like Corbett, Selous, Roosevelt, Bell, Hemingway, Ruark, etc... And after the first hunt, they keep reading.

So, plese take your time, make as lengthy posts as you see appropriate.

Once again, many thanks for your participation here.
 
@Shootist43 has that exactly correct. I hate travelling with multiple rifles, so I tend to use the .375 for everything. For tiny animals like Duiker and Suni, I use .375 solids. They produce a .375 entrance and exit wound and no issues for the taxidermist.

You are the one who should consider a book. A number of professional hunters have written anthologies of their hunting experiences in recent years. Almost nothing has been written about the final years of hunting in India.
Red Leg ,
I am most grateful to your kind comment . Personally , for a battery comprising a single rifle , l would choose a magnum .375 by Holland and Holland rather than a magnum .458 by Winchester , however , if l had difficulty shooting the bigger rifle , which this sportsman did. I see that your fondness of the magnum .375 matches my own. For fifty years l was not in contact with the international hunting world , until l found this forum. And it pleased me greatly to see the magnum .375 has never been superseded by anything modern.
 
When you say Bangladesh's current laws, does that mean that hunting by foreigners still is possible there?

I asked the same question few days ago, on another thread, and it was confirmed as possible.
 
Dear Mr Rahman, Sir,
I believe many will agree that your experience will not bore us. Also, I can say, the longer the better.

Many of us here, have been in theory exploring Africa and India (before their first international hunt) through literary works of old hands like Corbett, Selous, Roosevelt, Bell, Hemingway, Ruark, etc... And after the first hunt, they keep reading.

So, plese take your time, make as lengthy posts as you see appropriate.

Once again, many thanks for your participation here.
Mark Hunter
Your kind words are very supportive. I try keeping my accounts short but detailled enough , so that readers can get a clear picture of the scene without needing to read lots of text.
 
Your stories thus far have been excellent reading. I hope you have the time and patience to offer more stories on AH. I have nothing against reading African stories, but would have to say that reading stories about India would be just as interesting and exciting as Africa.
 
Your stories thus far have been excellent reading. I hope you have the time and patience to offer more stories on AH. I have nothing against reading African stories, but would have to say that reading stories about India would be just as interesting and exciting as Africa.
Trogon ,
Thank you so much for your kind words. African stories have a happier ending because we know that we can relive our adventures there today .
 
That was a great story, Mr. Rahman, and very interesting to read. I believe all of us here would like you to continue writing about them.
 
That was a great story, Mr. Rahman, and very interesting to read. I believe all of us here would like you to continue writing about them.
Nyati,
Thank you so much for your kind words. I have a few left . Next time , perhaps an account of Indian bear hunting ? I prefer telling stories with plenty of pictures which give the readers a good image of Shikar in India.
 

Forum statistics

Threads
57,537
Messages
1,233,385
Members
101,278
Latest member
CooperFerr
 

 

 

Latest posts

Latest profile posts

Grz63 wrote on Doug Hamilton's profile.
Hello Doug,
I am Philippe from France and plan to go hunting Caprivi in 2026, Oct.
I have read on AH you had some time in Vic Falls after hunting. May I ask you with whom you have planned / organized the Chobe NP tour and the different visits. (with my GF we will have 4 days and 3 nights there)
Thank in advance, I will appreciate your response.
Merci
Philippe
Grz63 wrote on Moe324's profile.
Hello Moe324
I am Philippe from France and plan to go hunting Caprivi in 2026, Oct.
I have read on AH you had some time in Vic Falls after hunting. May I ask you with whom you have planned / organized the Chobe NP tour and the different visits. (with my GF we will have 4 days and 3 nights there)
Thank in advance, I will appreciate your response.
Merci
Philippe
rafter3 wrote on Manny R's profile.
Hey there could I have that jewelers email you mentioned in the thread?
 
Top