I want to add a few thoughts about hunting these animals in wide open, wild areas. First, the hunt matters way more than the size on a truly wild, open area with no fences at all.
Sable - there are very few places where one can have a reasonable expectation to see, let alone kill, a sable of 45” or greater. The Kafue region of Zambia May be the single best place, but Matetsi in Zimbabwe and western Tanzania are the two other regions that come to mind. I’ve got 41” (Matetsi 3) 42” (Mlele South, western Tanzania) and 45” sable (Deka, Zimbabwe) and as far as I’m concerned they’re all excellent specimens. I’ve seen exactly 2 sable we thought would go 48” or better, one was on the Selinda block in Botswana in 1989 and the other was on Deka in 1983. We thought the Deka bull might go 49” and we almost got him killed but in the end shot the 45” bull. If I was going to personally attempt a bull above 45” I’d do it in the Kafue region, probably with Johnny DuPlooy or Fico Vidale.
Roan - There are even fewer places where one can hunt free ranging Roan and not many of those can produce an upper 20’s bull. You might find such a bull on some of Zambia’s Luangwa Valley blocks, but I doubt it. If I’m not mistaken most Zambian Roan shot top out in the mid-20’s. The only other countries I’m aware of where you can hunt wild, non-fenced roan are Tanzania and Cameroon. I’m not even considering what Zim might produce since there are only a few permits in the entire country. I know western Tanzania can produce big roan as a friend shot a 29” bull on Mlele South in 2021, I held the skull and it was a huge roan. There are a handful of western Tanzanian blocks where good Roan exist and some of those blocks, like Mlele, hold both species. I killed a 42” sable on Mlele and my friend killed a bigger sable and that monster roan. I saw both species on my hunt. But, if I’m going on a hunt specifically for a big Roan, I’m going to Cameroon. Cameroon, on the right blocks, has lots of roan. A year ago, we hunted hard for a big roan there and found what we thought might be a 27” bull, but couldn’t get him killed. I’m probably going to go back in 2027 for Roan & Buffalo, but will hunt a different block with a different company than where I hunted in 2024. And if I can find a 26-27” Roan I won’t be holding out for bigger.
That’s my unsolicited .02 worth on those two species.